Resonance Raman Results: Retraction

+ See all authors and affiliations

Science  03 Oct 1997:
Vol. 278, Issue 5335, pp. 17-20
DOI: 10.1126/science.278.5335.17h

We wish to alert readers that the resonance Raman spectra reported in two papers (Reports, D. Qiu et al., 6 May 1994, p. 817; M. Kumar et al., 27 Oct. 1995, p. 628) (1, 2) have been found to be unreliable and to consist of artifacts. However, the non-Raman data in both reports are reliable. We are confident that all the samples were properly prepared and contained the reaction intermediates under investigation. However, we have been unable to reproduce the Raman spectra with fresh samples, and judge the published spectra to be artifacts resulting from electronic processing of the data.

This retraction affects our main conclusions in both papers about the metal(s) to which CO and methyl bind in CODH, because these conclusions rested heavily on the reported isotope sensitivity of signals that we now consider spurious. We are working to produce positive new evidence regarding this topic.


Navigate This Article