Haldane's Rule in Taxa Lacking a Hemizygous X

See allHide authors and affiliations

Science  30 Oct 1998:
Vol. 282, Issue 5390, pp. 952-954
DOI: 10.1126/science.282.5390.952


Haldane's rule states that species hybrids of the XY sex are preferentially sterile or inviable. In all taxa known to obey this rule, the Y is inert and X-linked genes show full expression in XY individuals. Until recently, all theories of Haldane's rule depended on this hemizygosity. A test of Haldane's rule in animals lacking a hemizygous sex—mosquitoes having two functional sex chromosomes in both sexes—reveals that these species show Haldane's rule for sterility but not inviability. A related group having a “normal” hemizygous X obeys Haldane's rule for both sterility and inviability. These results support the faster male and dominance theories of Haldane's rule.

Mosquitoes of the genusAedes have single-locus sex determination: Although females are XX and males are XY, both X and Y chromosomes carry complete homologous sets of genes and differ only at a single locus (or small chromosome region) specifying sex. Cytological work reveals that the X and Y, which recombine throughout their lengths, are morphologically indistinguishable (1). Genetic analysis of more than 60 sex-linked, visible, electrophoretic and DNA markers confirms that the Y carries homologous alleles at all loci studied (1,2). Y gene activity has been confirmed in at least nine species of Aedes (1–3). Mosquitoes of the genus Anopheles, on the other hand, possess degenerate Y chromosomes and X-linked genes that show normal hemizygous expression and sex-linked patterns of inheritance (4).

The fact that Aedes lacks a hemizygous X, whereasAnopheles possesses one, allows several novel tests of the leading theories explaining Haldane's rule (5–7). Recent work suggests that Haldane's rule has two causes. The first, the so-called dominance theory, posits that the genes causing hybrid problems are mostly recessive (8–10). If so, XY individuals will suffer the full effects of all X-linked alleles causing hybrid problems, whereas XX individuals will partly mask such alleles in the heterozygous state. Consequently, the XY sex will suffer more severe hybrid problems than will the XX sex, and Haldane's rule results (8–10). Experiments with Drosophilasuggest that dominance explains Haldane's rule for hybrid inviability (11–13). Dominance may also contribute to Haldane's rule for sterility, although the evidence here is less direct (12–14).

A second force, faster male evolution, may also cause Haldane's rule for sterility (6). Because male and female fertility typically involve different loci, Haldane's rule might simply reflect a faster rate of divergence of genes involved in male than in female reproduction. If so, hybrid male sterility would tend to arise before hybrid female sterility, yielding Haldane's rule in taxa with XY males. Several causes of faster male evolution have been suggested (6), the most popular positing that sexual selection drives especially rapid evolution of male-expressed genes (6, 15). Recent experiments suggest that faster male evolution may give rise to Haldane's rule for sterility, at least in Drosophila (12, 16). The faster male theory cannot, however, be extended to hybrid inviability, because genes affecting viability almost always affect both sexes (lethal mutations within species almost invariably kill both sexes) (6, 12, 16). The faster male theory also cannot be extended to explain hybrid sterility in taxa such as birds and butterflies, in which heterogametic females are preferentially sterile (6, 10).

The consensus view of Haldane's rule is, therefore, simple: Haldane's rule for inviability appears to be caused by dominance alone, whereas in taxa with heterogametic males, Haldane's rule for sterility appears to be caused by both dominance and faster male evolution (7, 12,16, 17).

The contrast between Aedes and Anophelesprovides nearly ideal material for testing this view. These theories predict that: (i) If the faster male theory is correct,Aedes should obey Haldane's rule for sterility despite the fact that it lacks a hemizygous X. Because the faster male theory depends on sexual selection, it (unlike all other theories explaining Haldane's rule) can act in taxa lacking a hemizygous X. (ii) If dominance also causes Haldane's rule for sterility, then, all else being equal, a greater fraction of Anopheles thanAedes hybridizations should obey Haldane's rule for sterility. The reason is that two forces (faster male evolution and dominance) cause Haldane's rule in taxa having a hemizygous sex, whereas only one force (faster male evolution) causes Haldane's rule in taxa lacking a hemizygous sex. (iii) Considering Haldane's rule for inviability, Anopheles should show sex-limited inviability (with males preferentially affected), whereas Aedes should show little or no sex-limited inviability. Dominance, after all, is irrelevant to taxa lacking hemizygosity.

We collected data from the literature on species crosses inAedes and Anopheles. Considering only species crosses showing some reproductive isolation, and tabulating hybrid sterility and inviability separately, we classified the outcome of each species cross as “male-affected” hybrid problems, “female-affected” problems, or “both-sexes–affected” problems (18) (Tables 1 and 2).

Table 1

Aedes hybridizations. B, both sexes affected; M, males affected; F, females affected; N, neither sex affected. Dashes indicate no data or that data did not match criteria (18). Some hybridizations are reviewed in (23); a full list of references is available from the authors.

View this table:
Table 2

Anopheles hybridizations. B, both sexes affected; M, males affected; F, females affected; N, neither sex affected. Dashes indicate no data or that data did not match criteria (18). Anopheles hybridizations are reviewed in (23, 24); a full list of references is available from the authors.

View this table:

We consider our predictions in turn. First, Aedes obeys Haldane's rule for hybrid sterility (Table 3). Haldane's rule thus appears to extend beyond taxa having a hemizygous sex chromosome. Although we cannot be certain that all of the hybridizations in Table 3are phylogenetically independent, the fact that male-only hybrid sterility is routinely seen in Aedes (11 out of 11 cases), whereas female-only sterility is never seen, provides strong support for faster male evolution. This pattern of conformity to Haldane's rule for sterility is as strong as that seen in mammals and Lepidoptera (5–7). These results also show that faster male evolution cannot be due to a higher rate of substitution of recessive male-beneficial mutations on the X chromosome (12,17, 19), a process that depends on hemizygous selection of male-expressed genes and so cannot act inAedes. Thus, at least one of the forces causing Haldane's rule for sterility must act when the X is not hemizygous. Sexual selection, which clearly operates in the genus Aedes(20), seems a likely candidate (6).

Table 3

Summary of hybridizations.

View this table:

Second, the fraction of hybridizations showing Haldane's rule for sterility relative to those showing both-sex sterility is lower inAedes than in Anopheles: About one-half ofAedes versus three-quarters of Anopheles crosses show male-affected problems. Although alternative explanations of this trend are certainly possible (21), it is at least consistent with the trend expected if both faster male evolution and dominance cause Haldane's rule for sterility in taxa with a hemizygous sex.

Third, although Anopheles routinely shows sex-limited hybrid inviability, Aedes does not (Table 3). This observation supports the dominance theory: In Anopheles, recessive X-linked alleles might kill hybrid males but not females (as observed); in Aedes, on the other hand, any allele dominant enough to kill one hybrid sex should be dominant enough to kill the other as well, and thus most hybridizations should fall into the both-sexes–affected class (as observed) (22). It should be emphasized that the dominance theory would have been disproved ifAedes routinely showed sex-limited inviability or ifAnopheles did not. Instead both groups behave as predicted by the dominance theory.

Taken together, these findings provide support for the recent suggestion that Haldane's rule is caused by at least two evolutionary forces—dominance and faster male evolution.


View Abstract

Navigate This Article