+ See all authors and affiliations

Science  09 Jan 2015:
Vol. 347, Issue 6218, pp. 139
DOI: 10.1126/science.347.6218.139-a

Our Report “Single-proton spin detection by diamond magnetometry” (1) presents measurements on near-surface nitrogenvacancy centers in diamond. In these measurements, we observed signals that showed all the characteristics expected from single-proton nuclei. This interpretation was based on the three criteria of the Zeeman effect, quantum-coherent coupling, and (in one occasion) on a before/after-type control experiment.

We have discovered a potentially serious issue with the main conclusion in the paper, namely the “detection of a single-proton spin.” Specifically, we have recognized that resident carbon-13 nuclei within the diamond can mimic single-proton behavior, challenging our interpretation. Carbon-13 can produce quantum-coherent signals at the proton nuclear magnetic resonance frequency, and the scaling of frequency with magnetic field is indistinguishable from that of single protons within the measurement error. This behavior is due to an unrecognized effect that occurs with the dynamical decoupling sequence used for signal detection. We provide a detailed description of this behavior in a separate article (2).

Our Science Express Report claims single-proton spin detection in three instances. We find that two of these instances are ambiguous and can be explained by either single proton or single carbon-13, whereas the third instance can only be explained by single proton. Because this is only a single data point, we are not confident that it provides sufficient basis to support our claim of “single-proton spin detection.” We therefore retract the Report.


Related Content

Navigate This Article