Antarctic Ice Sheet variability across the Eocene-Oligocene boundary climate transition

See allHide authors and affiliations

Science  01 Apr 2016:
Vol. 352, Issue 6281, pp. 76-80
DOI: 10.1126/science.aab0669

Sensitive ice sheets

Why did the Antarctic Ice Sheet begin to grow 34 million years ago, and what does that have to do with us? Galeotti et al. studied a marine sediment core recovered from just off the coast of Antarctica (see the Perspective by Lear and Lunt). The ice sheet did not begin to grow until atmospheric CO2 concentrations had dropped to below around 600 parts per million. Indeed, the ice sheet was unstable when CO2 was higher. As modern atmospheric CO2 concentrations continue their rise, a shift back to an unstable Antarctic Ice Sheet could increase harmful rises in sea level.

Science, this issue p. 76; see also p. 34


About 34 million years ago, Earth’s climate cooled and an ice sheet formed on Antarctica as atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) fell below ~750 parts per million (ppm). Sedimentary cycles from a drillcore in the western Ross Sea provide direct evidence of orbitally controlled glacial cycles between 34 million and 31 million years ago. Initially, under atmospheric CO2 levels of ≥600 ppm, a smaller Antarctic Ice Sheet (AIS), restricted to the terrestrial continent, was highly responsive to local insolation forcing. A more stable, continental-scale ice sheet calving at the coastline did not form until ~32.8 million years ago, coincident with the earliest time that atmospheric CO2 levels fell below ~600 ppm. Our results provide insight into the potential of the AIS for threshold behavior and have implications for its sensitivity to atmospheric CO2 concentrations above present-day levels.

The establishment of the Antarctic Ice Sheet (AIS) is associated with an approximate +1.5 per mil increase in deep-water marine oxygen isotopic (δ18O) values beginning at ~34 million years ago (Ma) and peaking at ~33.6 Ma (13), with two positive δ18O steps separated by ~200,000 years. The first positive isotopic step primarily reflects a temperature decrease (4); the second isotopic step has been interpreted as the onset of a prolonged interval of maximum ice extent [Earliest Oligocene Glacial Maximum (EOGM)] between 33.6 and 33.2 Ma (5). Deep-water temperature cooled by 3° to 5°C (6) as a consequence of decreasing CO2 levels (7), while the volume of ice on Antarctica expanded to either near-modern dimensions (6, 8) or as much as 25% larger than present-day values (9, 10). A sea-level fall of ~70 m is estimated from low-latitude shallow-marine sequences (9, 11). Uncertainties in the magnitudes of these estimates in part reflect the limitations of geochemical proxy records used to deconvolve the relative contribution of ice volume and temperature at orbital resolution (12), as well as uncertainties inherent in the backstripping of continental margin sedimentary records (8). Ice sheet–proximal marine geological records from the continental margin of Antarctica can improve our understanding of the AIS evolution by providing evidence of the direct response of shallow-marine sedimentary environments (e.g., water depth changes) to ice sheet expansion and retreat.

The temporal pattern and extent of Late Eocene–Early Oligocene (~34.1 to ~31 Ma) Antarctic glacial advance and retreat is recorded in the well-dated CRP-3 drillcore, a shallow-water glaciomarine sedimentary succession deposited in the Victoria Land Basin (Fig. 1), tens of kilometers seaward of the present-day East Antarctic Ice Sheet (EAIS) in the Western Ross Sea (13). Thirty-seven fluvial to shallow-marine (deltaic) sedimentary cycles occur in the lower 500 m of the drillcore [330 to 780 m below sea floor (mbsf)] that record the advance and retreat of land-terminating glaciers delivering terrigenous sediment to an open wave–dominated coastline and are associated with relative sea level (RSL) oscillations of less than 20 m (14). These cycles, characterized as type B (Fig. 2; see also supplementary materials), do not display evidence of ice contact from glacial overriding. In contrast, 11 glaciomarine sedimentary cycles bounded by glacial surfaces of erosion in the upper 300 m of the drillcore (0 to 300 mbsf) reflect oscillations of the seaward extent of a marine-terminating ice sheet onto the Ross Sea continental shelf and across the CRP-3 drill site associated with larger RSL fluctuations of >20 m (14) (type A cycles in Fig. 2; see also supplementary materials). Temporal variations in lithofacies, grain size, and clast abundance primarily reflect oscillations in depositional energy that were controlled by changes in water depth and/or glacial proximity (14, 15). Shallow-marine sedimentary cycles analogous to those observed in the CRP-3 drillcore have been directly linked with orbitally driven climatic cycles of the AIS across the Oligocene-Miocene boundary at a nearby Ross Sea site (15). Accordingly, we applied a similar approach to directly compare the timing of proximal ice volume changes during the Early Oligocene against high-resolution temperature and ice volume proxy records derived from distal deep-sea sequences.

Fig. 1 Location of key geographical and geological features in Southern McMurdo Sound.

Boundary faults of the southern extension of Terror Rift are shown, together with the location of the CRP, MSSTS-1, and CIROS-1 drill sites.

Fig. 2 Astrochronological calibration of glacial events across the Eocene-Oligocene climate transitions.

(A) Deep-sea oxygen and carbon isotopic record from ODP Site 1218 (2, 17). (B to H) Time series for climatic precession (B), obliquity (C), and eccentricity (D) correlated with magnetostratigraphy (E), lithostratigraphy (F), sequence stratigraphy (G) (13, 14), and square root of clast abundance (H) (30) for the Late Eocene–Early Oligocene CRP-3 drillcore. Thirty-seven shallow-marine sedimentary cycles (sequences; type B) occur in the lower 500 m of the core record, controlled by advances and retreats of land-terminating glaciers associated with sea-level oscillations of less than 20 m. Eleven overlying glaciomarine sedimentary cycles (sequences; type A), each bounded by glacial surfaces of erosion, occur in the upper 300 m of the CRP-3 core, and record oscillations in the extent of a more expansive marine-terminating ice sheet in Ross Embayment. (I) Inferred stages and events in the development of the AIS across the Eocene-Oligocene boundary and their relationship to orbital forcing.

Clast abundance (Fig. 2) reflects glacial proximity and has been shown in a previous study to be controlled by orbital forcing in conjunction with the deposition of type B cycles in the lower part of CRP-3 (16). To similarly test for the role of orbital forcing within the laterally extensive glacial advances within the type A cycle succession in the upper 300 m of the CRP-3 core, we applied a singular spectrum analysis (see supplementary materials) to the clast abundance time series and a new record of luminance, which reflects changing proportions of clay and sand in sedimentary environments controlled by the proximity to the ice margin and by changes in water depth associated with RSL fluctuations (14). An independently derived age model for CRP-3, based on biochronologic calibration of a magnetic reversal stratigraphy (16), together with identification of the orbital components in these records enables a one-to-one correlation of sedimentary cycles to the highly resolved, orbitally tuned δ18O record from the deep sea (2, 17) (Fig. 2). A key age constraint in the CRP-3 record is the precisely dated transition (±5000 years) at 31.1 Ma between magnetic polarity chrons C12n and C12r at 12.5 mbsf (13) (fig. S5).

Variation in facies and clast abundance within type B shallow-marine sedimentary cycles have previously been interpreted to reflect periodic advance and retreat of land-terminating alpine glaciers in the Transantarctic Mountains (15) in response to precession and obliquity forcing (16) (Fig. 2). This direct response to orbitally paced local insolation forcing indicates a highly dynamic AIS that advanced and retreated during the early icehouse phase of the EOGM. The first sedimentary evidence of ice advance onto the Ross Sea continental shelf coincides with the deposition of unconformity-bound, type A sedimentary cycles beginning at 32.8 Ma, and marks an abrupt transition in AIS sensitivity to orbital forcing that was paced by longer-duration eccentricity cycles (Figs. 2 and 3). This phase is also associated with climate cooling and increased physical weathering, as evidenced by a change in clay mineralogy (18). Type A cycles (Fig. 2) have been interpreted to represent cyclic alternations in both grounding-line proximity and RSL change (14). According to glacial isostatic adjustment (GIA) theory and given the ice marginal position of the CRP-3 site, any proximal ice thickness variation would have triggered crustal and geoidal deformations such that the resulting local RSL change would be opposite in sign to eustatic trends and likely of larger amplitude (see supplementary materials). However, sedimentological evidence implies that glacial maxima and minima locally coincided with times of minimum and maximum RSL, respectively, for both type A and type B cycles (14). This implies that the GIA-induced RSL rise that was caused by the expansion and grounding of the ice sheet at the CRP-3 site was counterbalanced by a strong RSL drop as a consequence of the forebulge uplift driven by synchronous EAIS thickening. Therefore, we argue that the appearance of marine-grounded ice near the CRP-3 site was enhanced by flexural crustal uplift as the EAIS expanded, resulting in a RSL fall (>40 m) in phase with the hypothetical eustatic trend.

Fig. 3 Major glacial events recorded by clast abundance peaks from the CRP-3 core.

(A and B) Events [gray bands in (A)] are calibrated to the astrochronologically tuned δ18O record from ODP Site 1218 (B) (2). (C) Major peaks in clast abundance from CRP-3 correspond to the onset of the EOT-1 shift and glacial maxima at the Oi1 and Oi1a, and are associated with prolonged intervals characterized by cold southern high latitude summers as expressed in the 70°S mean summer insolation. (D) AIS volume changes recorded by the sedimentary sequences and clast abundance (see Fig. 2) are paced by the influence of obliquity and precession on a smaller-sized terrestrial ice sheet between 34.2 and 32.8 Ma. (E) Comparison with available atmospheric pCO2 (partial pressure of atmospheric CO2) records based on boron isotope (21) and alkenone (7) proxies shows that the earliest evidence of ice sheet grounding in the CRP-3 core occurs at the Oi1a event (32.9 to 32.8 Ma), coincident with a major peak in clast abundance and a longer-term drop in atmospheric CO2 to below ~600 ppm.

Both petrological and apatite fission track evidence (19) suggests that diamictites deposited as part of 400,000-year sedimentary cycles spanning ~17 to 157 mbsf (~32.0 to 31.1 Ma; Fig. 2) were derived both locally from the Mackay glacier and from the southern Transantarctic Mountains outlet glaciers during glacial overriding and downcutting. Flowlines that trend northwestward into McMurdo Sound from the Byrd, Skelton, and Mulock glaciers are implied by model simulation of the early Oligocene glacial expansion (10, 20).

According to our chronology and geological evidence for ice grounding, a marine-calving ice sheet first occurred in the western Ross Embayment at ~32.8 Ma, about 1 million years after the glacial maximum (Oi1) inferred by δ18O values from marine carbonate isotope records (17) (Figs. 2 and 3). Oxygen isotope values paired with southern high-latitude Mg/Ca records (3) indicate that the AIS volume was slightly larger across Oi1a (~32.8 Ma) than across the EOGM. The Oi1a shift coincides, within the degree of uncertainty shown in Fig. 3 (see also fig. S17), with the CO2 minimum [~600 ppm by volume (ppmv)] at the end of a ~40% decline beginning in the late Eocene (7, 21) (Fig. 3). Declining CO2 levels that culminate during Oi1a are fully consistent with model-derived CO2 thresholds for Antarctic glaciation (20). The Oi1a interval also corresponds to a long-term minimum in eccentricity and obliquity (22), similar to the orbital configuration favoring the onset of glaciation across Oi1 (Fig. 3), implying that an extended period of low seasonality with cooler summers contributed to these long-period glacial maxima.

Therefore, we argue that despite ice expansion during the EOGM, the nascent AIS was strongly sensitive to orbitally paced, local insolation forcing until a CO2 threshold of ~600 ppmv was crossed at 32.8 Ma (Fig. 3 and fig. S17). After 32.8 Ma, an expanded continental-scale ice sheet displayed progressively stronger orbital ice sheet hysteresis; such behavior is also suggested by ice models (20, 23). Our observations from the CRP-3 record are also consistent with far-field ice volume proxies that indicate RSL changes of ~25 m in the time interval 33.4 to 32.8 Ma (9, 11), equivalent to ~40% of present-day AIS volume. By contrast, after 32.8 Ma, a protracted period of RSL stability is observed in δ18O records, which corresponds with our proximal evidence for an AIS that was relatively insensitive to higher-frequency orbital forcing (11) until ~29 Ma, when CO2 values again increased to >600 ppm (24) (fig. S17). Our observations of AIS history and behavior lead us to conclude that the partial pressure of atmospheric CO2 was the primary influence on the overall climate state and variability of AIS volume, including its sensitivity to orbital forcing, which implies a close linkage between carbon cycle dynamics and AIS evolution on both long- and short-period orbital time scales. Indeed, amplification of the long-period eccentricity component—observed in the CRP-3 record at ~32 Ma—tracks the establishment of low-latitude δ13C variability with a 405,000-year periodicity (25).

The general orbital coherence and phasing between glacial cycles and marine δ13C records (Fig. 2) indicates that carbon cycle feedbacks contributed to CO2 changes and amplification of short- and long-period eccentricity–paced glacial-interglacial cycles in the Early Oligocene (26), similar to the climate-carbon cycle dynamics associated with Northern Hemisphere glacial cycles during the Pleistocene. Coupled global climate–ice sheet models predict that the AIS should display threshold-like behavior in response to long-term trends in atmospheric CO2 levels (20). For example, the stability threshold for marine-based sectors of the AIS has been shown to be ~400 ppm; between 300 and 400 ppm, marine ice sheets are highly dynamic in response to orbital forcing (27, 28). Intermodel comparisons suggest a larger range of atmospheric CO2 values (~560 to 920 ppm) for AIS glaciation (29). Data presented in our study imply that a CO2 threshold for a continental-scale Antarctic ice sheet occurred at ~600 ppm, and that AIS sensitivity to insolation forcing and vulnerability to melt can be expected to increase markedly between 600 and 750 ppm.

Supplementary Materials

Materials and Methods

Figs. S1 to S17

References (3149)

References and Notes

Acknowledgments: This research is an outcome of a 2-year project (PNRA 2004/4.09) partly funded by Programma Nazionale di Ricerche in Antartide (Italy). Also supported by NSF grants ANT-0424589, 1043018, and OCE-1202632 and by New Zealand Ministry of Business Innovation and Employment contract C05X1001(TN). Data are available from
View Abstract

Navigate This Article