Mitochondrial endonuclease G mediates breakdown of paternal mitochondria upon fertilization

See allHide authors and affiliations

Science  22 Jul 2016:
Vol. 353, Issue 6297, pp. 394-399
DOI: 10.1126/science.aaf4777

Eliminating paternal mitochondria

During fertilization, the oocyte and sperm each bring their mitochondria to the union. Shortly afterward, the paternal mitochondria are degraded, and only the maternal mitochondria are conveyed to the progeny. Zhou et al. observed that the integrity of the inner membrane of paternal mitochondria is compromised, which apparently marks them for degradation (see the Perspective by van der Bliek). Autophagy commences by mitochondrial endonuclease G relocating from the intermembrane space into the matrix and subsequently degrading the paternal mitochondrial DNA. Any delay in this process increases embryonic lethality.

Science, this issue p. 394; see also p. 351


Mitochondria are inherited maternally in most animals, but the mechanisms of selective paternal mitochondrial elimination (PME) are unknown. While examining fertilization in Caenorhabditis elegans, we observed that paternal mitochondria rapidly lose their inner membrane integrity. CPS-6, a mitochondrial endonuclease G, serves as a paternal mitochondrial factor that is critical for PME. We found that CPS-6 relocates from the intermembrane space of paternal mitochondria to the matrix after fertilization to degrade mitochondrial DNA. It acts with maternal autophagy and proteasome machineries to promote PME. Loss of cps-6 delays breakdown of mitochondrial inner membranes, autophagosome enclosure of paternal mitochondria, and PME. Delayed removal of paternal mitochondria causes increased embryonic lethality, demonstrating that PME is important for normal animal development. Thus, CPS-6 functions as a paternal mitochondrial degradation factor during animal development.

Mitochondria are critical for many cellular processes including cellular respiration, apoptosis, and metabolism, and they possess their own genome (mtDNA) (1, 2). However, only maternal mitochondria are passed on to progeny. Although elimination of paternal mtDNA can occur at various developmental stages through different mechanisms (3), it is unclear why and how paternal mitochondria are selectively eliminated after fertilization during embryo development (3, 4). To address these questions, we examined paternal mitochondria in C. elegans spermatozoa and embryos by electron microscopy (EM) and tomography.

Mitochondria in wild-type (N2) spermatozoa are spherical (fig. S1A), with an average diameter of 464 ± 68 nm (SD), and their cristae, formed by extensive infolding of the inner membrane, uniformly distribute in the matrix (Fig. 1A). Paternal mitochondria in N2 zygotes are readily distinguished from the tubular and thinner maternal mitochondria (with an average width of 238 ± 57 nm; fig. S1B). Notably, all paternal mitochondria in N2 zygotes have multiple dark aggregates (agg) in the matrix that form promptly after their entry into oocytes (Fig. 1, B and E, fig. S1, B to G, and movie S1). The double-layer membranes from autophagosomes have started to assemble around some paternal mitochondria at this stage (fig. S1B). We named paternal mitochondria containing small aggregates that lack nearby autophagosome membranes “small agg PM” (Fig. 1B). Those containing larger aggregates that are associated with autophagosome membranes are called “large agg PM” (Fig. 1C), and those with few cristae and enclosed in an autophagosome are called “ghost PM” (Fig. 1D). Many small agg PM arise independently of the autophagy machinery (Fig. 1, B and E, fig. S1, B to G, and movie S1). Large agg PM and ghost PM are observed in N2 zygotes but are mostly seen in two- or four-cell–stage embryos (Fig. 1, C to E).

Fig. 1 Loss of cps-6 delays internal breakdown of paternal mitochondria after fertilization.

(A to D, F to J) Tomographic slice images and corresponding 3D models of a mitochondrion in an N2 (A) or cps-6(tm3222) (F) spermatozoon or a paternal mitochondrion in an N2 embryo [(B) to (D)] or a cps-6(tm3222) embryo [(G) to (J)] at the indicated stages. 3D models of autophagosomes (AuPh) and endoplasmic reticulum (ER) are shown. Mitochondrial membranes, cristae, and aggregates are colored red, green, and blue, respectively. Dark aggregates and autophagosome membranes are indicated with blue and yellow arrowheads, respectively. Scale bars, 300 nm. (E) Histogram showing three classes of paternal mitochondria in embryos of different stages from the indicated N2 cross (n = 45) or cps-6(tm3222) cross (n = 56).

In large agg PM, cristae are cleared from the central region as the aggregates enlarge in the matrix (Fig. 1C), which occurs before autophagosomes enclose paternal mitochondria. Once enclosed by autophagosomes, they lose matrix contents except for some remaining aggregates, but their outer membrane does not rupture until most of the cristae have disappeared (Fig. 1D and fig. S1H). These results suggest that paternal mitochondria are destroyed partly in embryos by self-initiated internal breakdown prior to autophagosome assembly and degradation.

To identify intrinsic mitochondrial factors involved in paternal mitochondrial elimination (PME), we performed an RNA interference (RNAi) screen against 217 C. elegans nuclear genes predicted to encode mitochondrial proteins (table S1), using a sensitive polymerase chain reaction (PCR)–based method and a 3053–base pair (bp) mtDNA deletion allele (uaDf5; Fig. 2A) to track the fate of mtDNA (5). uaDf5 mtDNA was detected in cross-progeny at all developmental stages from mating of N2 males with uaDf5/+ heteroplasmic hermaphrodites (fig. S2A) (5) but was detected only in early embryos, not in late embryos nor in larval cross-progeny from N2 hermaphrodites mated with uaDf5/+ males (Fig. 2B); these findings indicate that PME is conserved in C. elegans (57). RNAi of the cps-6 gene, which encodes a homolog of human mitochondrial endonuclease G (8, 9), caused persistence of paternal uaDf5 mtDNA until the late stages of embryogenesis—a finding not observed in RNAi of other genes (fig. S2B and supplementary materials). A 336-bp deletion (tm3222) in cps-6, which removes the catalytic site of CPS-6 (fig. S2C) (10), had the same effect as cps-6(RNAi), leading to persistence of paternal uaDf5 mtDNA throughout embryo development (Fig. 2C), whereas uaDf5 was detected only in 64-cell or earlier embryos in crosses between uaDf5/+ males and N2 hermaphrodites (Fig. 2B). These results indicate that cps-6 is associated with rapid removal of paternal mtDNA during early embryogenesis.

Fig. 2 CPS-6 relocates from the intermembrane space of paternal mitochondria to the matrix after fertilization to promote PME.

(A) Diagram of C. elegans mtDNA, the uaDf5 deletion, primers used in the nested PCR assays, and sizes of PCR products in N2 and uaDf5/+ animals. (B and C) Hermaphrodites and MTR-stained males were mated as indicated. Males also carried smIs42, an integrated Psur-5sur-5::gfp transgene used to track cross progeny (see fig. S2A). A single unfertilized oocyte and a single cross-fertilized embryo or larva (MTR- or GFP-positive) at the indicated stage was analyzed by PCR. uaDf5/+ and N2 hermaphrodites were controls. (D) Quantification of MTR-stained paternal mitochondrial clusters in 64-cell embryos from the indicated crosses with MTR-stained males. Data are means ± SEM; n = 20 per cross. **P < 0.0001 (unpaired Student t test); n.s., not significant. (E and F) Five cross-fertilized embryos (E) or transgenic embryos (F) at approximately 100-cell stage from the indicated crosses were analyzed by PCR. (G to J) Representative immuno-EM images of mitochondria in N2 spermatozoa and paternal mitochondria in zygotes from the indicated cross. CPS-6–specific and PD-E2–specific immunogold particles are marked with arrowheads. Scale bars, 300 nm. (K) Histogram of the distances of 15-nm immunogold particles from the mitochondrial membrane, illustrating CPS-6’s movement after fertilization. Numbers of immunogold particles scored are shown in parentheses. ***P < 0.0001 (Mann-Whitney U test). cps-6(tm3222) was used in all figures.

We performed microscopic analysis to monitor the disappearance of paternal mitochondria stained by Mitotracker Red (MTR), a mitochondrion-specific dye (5). When MTR-stained N2 males were mated with unstained N2 hermaphrodites, MTR-stained paternal mitochondria were seen in embryos before the 64-cell stage (fig. S3, A to G), indicating that PME occurs in concert with paternal mtDNA elimination (Fig. 2B). Conversely, loss of cps-6 resulted in persistence of MTR paternal mitochondria to around the 550-cell stage (fig. S3, H to N), confirming that CPS-6 promotes rapid clearance of paternal mitochondria.

Fig. 3 Depolarization of paternal mitochondria after fertilization and autophagosome formation on paternal mitochondria.

(A and B) Differential interference contrast (DIC) and fluorescence images of zygotes from the indicated crosses. TMRE had equal access to maternal and paternal mitochondria in the zygote (B). Scale bars, 10 μm. (C to F) Zygotes from the indicated crosses with MTR-stained males were labeled with an antibody to LGG-1. Images were acquired with a Nikon SIM microscope. Dashed rectangles highlight the areas enlarged and shown below [(D) and (F)]. Scale bars, 2 μm [(C) and (E)], 0.5 μm [(D) and (F)].

CPS-6 was first identified as an apoptotic nuclease that translocates from mitochondria to the nucleus during apoptosis to mediate chromosome fragmentation (8, 9). A nonapoptotic role of CPS-6 in C. elegans has not been reported. We used both the PCR assay and the microscopic assay to investigate whether CPS-6 is required paternally or maternally for PME (supplementary text) and found that a significant portion of paternal mitochondria and mtDNA persisted past the 64-cell stage when paternal cps-6 was defective (Fig. 2, D and E, matings 3 and 4). By contrast, embryos without maternal cps-6 displayed normal PME (Fig. 2, D and E, mating 2). These results indicate that paternal CPS-6 is required to promote PME.

CPS-6 is imported into mitochondria through a mitochondrial targeting sequence (amino acids 1 to 21), because CPS-6ΔN, lacking this targeting sequence, localizes to the nucleus (8). Expression of CPS-6, but not CPS-6ΔN, in cps-6(tm3222) males through the ubiquitously expressed dpy-30 gene promoter rescued the defect in PME (Fig. 2F, matings 1, 2, and 5 to 7; see also supplementary text), indicating that localization of CPS-6 in paternal mitochondria is required to mediate PME. Because expression of the nuclease-deficient CPS-6(H148A) mutant in cps-6(tm3222) males failed to rescue the PME defect (Fig. 2F, matings 3 and 4), the nuclease activity of CPS-6 is essential for PME.

Using electron tomography, we examined how loss of cps-6 affects PME. In cps-6(tm3222) zygotes, aggregates were still visible in paternal mitochondria but were smaller and fewer than in N2 zygotes, and no ghost PM were detected (Fig. 1, B, E, and G), indicating reduced and slower internal breakdown of paternal mitochondria. The autophagosome membranes started to assemble around paternal mitochondria in two- or four-cell cps-6(tm3222) embryos and completed enclosure by the 16-cell stage (Fig. 1, H and I), proceeding significantly slower than in N2 embryos, in which autophagosome assembly started earlier at the one-cell stage and was complete by the four-cell stage (Fig. 1, C to E). Even after autophagosome enclosure, internal breakdown of paternal mitochondria was clearly delayed (Fig. 1, I and J), because a significant portion of cristae remained superficially intact and fewer than 40% of paternal mitochondria transited into ghost PM in 16-cell cps-6(tm3222) embryos (Fig. 1E). Some large agg PM even lingered on in 64-cell embryos (Fig. 1J), compared with 100% of paternal mitochondria either eliminated or becoming ghost PM by the four-cell N2 embryos (Fig. 1, D and E). Therefore, CPS-6 is important in mediating internal breakdown of paternal mitochondria and their enclosure by autophagosomes after fertilization.

Compromised mitochondria often show loss of membrane potential, which can be detected by tetramethylrhodamine ethyl ester (TMRE), a potential-sensitive mitochondrial dye. When N2 males prestained with TMRE and a nucleic acid dye (SYTO11)—which labeled sperm mitochondria and their mtDNA, respectively (fig. S4, A and B)—were mated with N2 hermaphrodites, paternal mitochondria were still labeled by SYTO11 in N2 zygotes, but their TMRE staining was completely lost (Fig. 3A). In comparison, staining of paternal mitochondria by potential-insensitive MTR persisted (fig. S4B). When we mated SYTO11-stained N2 males with N2 hermaphrodites in the presence of TMRE, only maternal mitochondria were stained by TMRE, and the SYTO11-positive paternal mitochondria were TMRE-negative (Fig. 3B). Therefore, paternal mitochondria are depolarized shortly after fertilization, preceding degradation of their mtDNA.

We used immuno-EM to determine the localization of CPS-6 in paternal mitochondria. CPS-6 immunogold particles were predominantly associated with the mitochondrial membrane in N2 spermatozoa (Fig. 2, G and K, and fig. S2G), in agreement with CPS-6’s localization in mitochondrial intermembrane space. In zygotes from cps-6(tm3222) hermaphrodites mated with N2 males, CPS-6 immunogold particles were often located inside paternal mitochondria, away from the mitochondrial membrane (Fig. 2, H and K, and fig. S5). Because some paternal mitochondria had not been associated with autophagosomes (Fig. 2H), CPS-6 appeared to enter the matrix before the assembly of autophagosomes. The relocation of CPS-6 into the matrix after fertilization is clearly discerned when compared with the localization patterns of a mitochondrial matrix protein, the E2 subunit of pyruvate dehydrogenase (PD-E2, Fig. 2, I to K). Collectively, these different microscopy analyses provide strong evidence that paternal mitochondria are depolarized and damaged internally soon after fertilization, leading to the release of CPS-6 into the matrix to catalyze mtDNA degradation.

The autophagy and proteasome pathways promote PME in C. elegans (57). Both LGG-1, the worm LC3/Atg8 homolog necessary for autophagosome formation (11), and RAD-23, a ubiquitin receptor important for proteasomal degradation (5, 12), act maternally to promote PME (fig. S6, A and B, and supplementary text). Analyses of the double and the triple mutants among cps-6, lgg-1, and rad-23 indicate that cps-6, lgg-1, and rad-23 use distinct mechanisms (mitochondrial self-destruction, autophagy, and proteasomes, respectively) to coordinate swift and efficient PME (fig. S6, C to F).

Because loss of cps-6 slows down autophagosome formation and degradation of paternal mitochondria (Fig. 1), we further interrogated this issue by immunostaining; we found that in N2 zygotes, bright LGG-1 staining was seen clustering around MTR-stained paternal mitochondria near the site of sperm entry (fig. S4C), with 81% of paternal mitochondrial clusters colocalizing with LGG-1 autophagosomes (fig. S4E). By contrast, in cps-6(tm3222) zygotes, such colocalization dropped to 43% (fig. S4, D and E), indicating that loss of cps-6 reduces autophagosome formation on paternal mitochondria. Analysis using superresolution structured illumination microscopy (SIM) revealed similar results. In N2 zygotes, the majority (77%) of paternal mitochondria were enclosed by LGG-1 autophagosomes, some (12%) were partially enclosed, and only 11% did not associate with (isolated) autophagosomes (Fig. 3, C and D, and fig. S4, F and H). By contrast, in cps-6(tm3222) zygotes, 51% of paternal mitochondria were isolated and only 29 and 20% of paternal mitochondria were enclosed and partially enclosed by autophagosomes, respectively (Fig. 3, E and F, and fig. S4, G and H). These findings indicate that the CPS-6 self-destruction process is important for efficient recruitment of autophagosomes to paternal mitochondria.

It has been suggested that the high rate of energy consumption during fertilization of an oocyte by many competing spermatozoa leads to increased oxidative damage and mutations in sperm mtDNA (13, 14). Failure to remove paternal mitochondria with mutated mtDNA can cause incompatibility with maternal mitochondria and the nuclear genome and can adversely affect the fitness of animals (1517). Comparison of N2 embryos with uaDf5/+ embryos, with four genes deleted in uaDf5 mtDNA (18), revealed a factor of 23 increase in embryonic lethality from 0.4 to 9.4% (Fig. 4A, assays 1 and 3), indicating that the heteroplasmic presence of mtDNA mutations compromises embryo development. Delayed removal of uaDf5 paternal mitochondria in embryos by loss of cps-6 resulted in a lethality rate of 5.9%, higher by a factor of 5 to 7 than that of cross-fertilized cps-6(tm3222) embryos (0.7%) or that of embryos with no persistent paternal mitochondria (0.8 to 0.9%) (Fig. 4A, assays 4 to 7, and supplementary text). Moreover, delayed clearance of uaDf5 paternal mitochondria slowed cell divisions, an energy-driven process, during C. elegans embryogenesis, because the average durations of cell divisions in two different cell lineages (MS and P) were significantly prolonged in uaDf5/+ embryos and by delayed removal of uaDf5 paternal mitochondria (Fig. 4, B and C, fig. S7, and supplementary text). These results provide evidence that delayed clearance of mutated paternal mitochondria leads to decreased fitness at the cellular and organismal levels and presents an evolutionary disadvantage.

Fig. 4 Delayed removal of paternal mitochondria increases embryonic lethality and cell division durations.

(A to D) The embryonic lethality rate [(A) and (D)] and durations of cell divisions in the MS lineage (B) and P lineage (C) were scored in self-fertilized embryos (1 to 3) or cross-fertilized embryos from crosses (4 to 7) of the indicated genotypes. All males carried smIs42 and were stained with MTR to assist identification of zygotes [(B) and (C)]. Data are means ± SEM; n > 1000 embryos per cross at 25°C [(A) and (D)] and n = 3 embryos per cross at 20°C [(B) and (C)]. *P < 0.05, **P < 0.001 (unpaired Student t test).

Next, we examined the consequence of delayed removal of wild-type paternal mitochondria by mating two different C. elegans wild-type strains, the Bristol strain (N2) and the Hawaii strain (HA). Delayed removal of wild-type Bristol paternal mitochondria in HA embryos due to loss of paternal cps-6 also resulted in a significantly higher percentage of embryonic lethality than that seen in HA embryos without persistent paternal mitochondria (Fig. 4D, assays 4 and 5, and fig. S6G, matings 2 and 4; see also supplementary text). Therefore, delayed clearance of wild-type paternal mitochondria slightly different from maternal mitochondria also compromises animal development, which suggests that transmission of paternal mitochondria among different wild-type variants is evolutionarily disadvantageous.

Our results show that soon after fertilization, paternal mitochondria are depolarized and lose their inner membrane integrity, which apparently marks them for degradation by autophagy (19, 20). The inner membrane breakdown probably triggers the entry of the intermembrane CPS-6 into the matrix of paternal mitochondria to degrade mtDNA, which encodes 12 mitochondrial proteins, two rRNAs, and 22 tRNAs that are essential for normal functions and maintenance of mitochondria (1, 13, 18). Degradation of mtDNA is detrimental, which accelerates breakdown of paternal mitochondria and could promote, externalization of signals recognized by the autophagy or proteasome machinery (19, 20), leading to PME (fig. S8). Consistent with this model, loss of paternal cps-6 delays internal breakdown of paternal mitochondria and their enclosure and degradation by the autophagy machinery. Interestingly, delayed removal of either mutant or slightly different wild-type paternal mitochondria results in increased embryonic lethality in heteroplasmic animals, likely due to incompatibility in cellular signaling between the mitochondrial and nuclear genomes (15, 17). This provides evidence that persistence of paternal mitochondria compromises animal development and may be the impetus for maternal inheritance of mitochondria. DeLuca and O'Farrell showed that endonuclease G mediated the degradation of sperm mitochondrial DNA during Drosophila spermatogenesis before fertilization and hypothesized that this degradation helped prevent paternal mtDNA transmission (21). In contrast, we find in C. elegans that CPS-6 acts after fertilization to mediate degradation of both paternal mitochondria and mtDNA to facilitate their autophagic degradation. These findings imply a conserved role of endonuclease G in paternal mtDNA elimination and expand the roles of this nuclease beyond apoptosis and mitochondrial maintenance (8, 9, 22).

Supplementary Materials

Materials and Methods

Supplementary Text

Figs. S1 to S8

Table S1

Movie S1

References (2337)

References and Notes

Acknowledgments: We thank T. Blumenthal, R. Poyton, and K. Krauter for comments and H. Zhang for strains and antibodies. Supported by March of Dimes grant 1-FY14-300 and NIH grants GM59083, GM79097, and GM118188 (D.X.) and Research Grants Council of Hong Kong grant AoE/M-05/12 (B.-H.K.).
View Abstract


Navigate This Article