Structure of the human TRPM4 ion channel in a lipid nanodisc

See allHide authors and affiliations

Science  12 Jan 2018:
Vol. 359, Issue 6372, pp. 228-232
DOI: 10.1126/science.aar4510

Architecture of the TRPM subfamily

Transient receptor potential melastatin (TRPM) ion channels constitute the largest TRP subfamily and are involved in many physiological processes. TRPM8 is the primary cold and menthol sensor, and TRPM4 is associated with cardiovascular disorders. Yin et al. and Autzen et al. shed light on the general architecture of the TRPM subfamily by solving the structures of TRPM8 and TRPM4, respectively (see the Perspective by Bae et al.). The three-layered architecture of the TRPM8 channel provides the framework for understanding the mechanisms of cold and menthol sensing. The two distinct closed states of TRPM4, with and without calcium, reveal a calcium-binding site and calcium-binding-induced conformational changes.

Science, this issue p. 237, p. 228; see also p. 160


Transient receptor potential (TRP) melastatin 4 (TRPM4) is a widely expressed cation channel associated with a variety of cardiovascular disorders. TRPM4 is activated by increased intracellular calcium in a voltage-dependent manner but, unlike many other TRP channels, is permeable to monovalent cations only. Here we present two structures of full-length human TRPM4 embedded in lipid nanodiscs at ~3-angstrom resolution, as determined by single-particle cryo–electron microscopy. These structures, with and without calcium bound, reveal a general architecture for this major subfamily of TRP channels and a well-defined calcium-binding site within the intracellular side of the S1-S4 domain. The structures correspond to two distinct closed states. Calcium binding induces conformational changes that likely prime the channel for voltage-dependent opening.

Transient receptor potential (TRP) channels comprise an extended superfamily of membrane ion channels that mediate diverse cellular and physiological functions. Permeability to both mono- and divalent cations is a defining feature for the majority of TRP channels (1). However, the TRP melastatin subfamily member 4 (TRPM4) channel is impermeable to Ca2+ yet is activated by intracellular Ca2+ (2). Activation of TRPM4 depolarizes the plasma membrane through Na+ entry, which in turn enhances Ca2+ influx through Ca2+-permeable channels or otherwise modulates Ca2+ oscillations (2, 3). Like many other TRP channel subtypes, TRPM4 displays voltage sensitivity, as evidenced by pronounced outward rectification of Ca2+-activated TRPM4 currents in response to voltage ramps (4). Binding of Ca2+ to TRPM4 is hypothesized to precede voltage-dependent opening, thereby giving rise to two closed states: Ca2+-unbound and Ca2+-bound (5). However, it is unclear where the Ca2+-binding site is located in the channel, and a structural basis for voltage sensitivity and ion selectivity remains elusive. Here we present two single-particle cryo–electron microscopy (cryo-EM) structures of the human TRPM4 channel in nanodiscs, in both Ca2+-bound and -unbound closed states. Comparison of the two structures reveals a Ca2+-binding site in the transmembrane domain, as well as conformational changes induced by Ca2+. Lipid molecules, including cholesteryl hemisuccinate (CHS), form tight interactions with the channel, likely stabilizing it in the lipid bilayer.

Recombinant full-length human TRPM4 (hTRPM4b) was purified in detergent and reconstituted into lipid nanodiscs, as described for other TRP ion channels (6) (fig. S1). Three-dimensional reconstructions with C4 symmetry were obtained in the presence of either 5 mM EDTA or CaCl2 to overall resolutions of 3.2 and 3.1 Å, respectively (Fig. 1, A and B, and figs. S2, A to F, and S3, A to F). In both structures, the transmembrane domain and part of the soluble domain are well resolved. However, the soluble regions distal to the membrane and the symmetry axis are of lower resolution, indicating conformational flexibility (figs. S2G and S3G). Focused refinement of the transmembrane domain with the central coiled-coil improved the local resolution and enabled de novo atomic model building of these domains for both samples (figs. S2, F and H; S3, F and H; S4, B and D; and S5). For the rest of the cytoplasmic domains, further classification and focused refinement of individual monomers without symmetry improved the resolution to a level sufficient for de novo model building (Fig. 1, C to F and figs. S2, I to K; S3, I to K; S4, C and E; and S5). The complete data processing scheme is described in the supplementary methods and fig. S4.

Fig. 1 Cryo-EM structure of hTRPM4.

(A and B) Side (A) and top (B) views of unsharpened (transparent light blue) and sharpened cryo-EM density maps of hTRPM4 in nanodiscs, with each subunit colored differently. (C) Atomic model of the tetrameric hTRPM4 in ribbons, in the same orientation and colors as the density map in (A). (D) Atomic model of the hTRPM4b monomer in ribbons, with domains labeled. (E) Bottom view of the hTRPM4 structure, showing interactions between neighboring subunits. (F) Schematic representation of the major structural components in hTPPM4b. Dashed lines denote regions where density was insufficient for model building. Each domain is labeled and color coded to match the domain representation in (D).

The transmembrane core contains six helices (S1 to S6) arranged in a domain-swapped architecture (Fig. 1, C and D) reminiscent of many tetrameric voltage-gated cation channels and all other TRP channels to date (713). hTRPM4 has additional membrane-embedded fragments that surround the S1-S4 domain at the inner leaflet of the membrane (Fig. 1, D and F), a feature that might be distinct to the TRPM subfamily. The C terminus of each subunit joins to form a parallel coiled-coil resembling that of the TRPA1 channel (11). The coiled-coil is surrounded by a large, intertwined cytoplasmic domain composed of four N-terminal TRPM homology regions (MHR1 to MHR4), which are highly conserved within the TRPM subfamily (14). MHR1 and MHR2 contain an eight-stranded β sheet surrounded by eight α helices. MHR3 and MHR4 are composed of stacked α helices and are linked to the transmembrane domain through MHR4, which clasps the TRP domain, thereby forming an interaction between the cytoplasmic domain and the transmembrane core (Fig. 1D). Between neighboring monomers, MHR1 of one subunit interacts with MHR3 of the adjacent subunit to form a ring that does not interact with the central coiled-coil (Fig. 1E).

Comparison of Ca2+-free and Ca2+-bound structures reveals an extra density in a hydrophilic pocket within the cytoplasmic side of the S1-S4 domain (Fig. 2A and fig. S6). Several lines of analysis suggest that this density represents a bona fide bound Ca2+ ion: (i) Direct comparison between both half maps and the combined maps of the CaCl2 and EDTA samples confirms the existence and precise location of the additional density in the CaCl2 map (fig. S6, A to C and E to G). (ii) The omit densities calculated as the difference between the experimental maps and a map calculated from the refined atomic models without Ca2+ show a strong density corresponding to a bound Ca2+ ion (fig. S6D) in the CaCl2 structure, but not in the EDTA structure. (iii) The difference map between the CaCl2 and EDTA maps reveals a clear density with a high signal-to-noise ratio (Fig. 2A and fig. S6H). (iv) Finally, side chain densities of surrounding negatively charged residues are stronger in the CaCl2 structure than in the EDTA structure (fig. S6, A and E), consistent with the observation that negatively charged side chains are generally weaker in a cryo-EM density map unless they are engaged in specific interactions (15).

Fig. 2 The Ca2+-binding site.

(A) Coordination of the bound Ca2+ ion by Glu828, Gln831, Asn865, and Asp868, with distances labeled. The density of the CaCl2 structure (gray mesh) is contoured at σ = 5 and overlaid with the difference density (blue mesh) between the CaCl2 structure and the EDTA structure, contoured at σ = 14. (B) Ca2+-binding site within the S1-S4 domain in the absence of a bound ion. (C) The same site with a bound ion. Side chains are labeled. The bound Ca2+ ion is shown in magenta. Single-letter abbreviations for the amino acid residues are as follows: A, Ala; C, Cys; D, Asp; E, Glu; F, Phe; G, Gly; H, His; I, Ile; K, Lys; L, Leu; M, Met; N, Asn; P, Pro; Q, Gln; R, Arg; S, Ser; T, Thr; V, Val; W, Trp; and Y, Tyr.

The Ca2+ ion is directly coordinated by side chains of Glu828 and Gln831 from S2 and Asn865 from S3 (Fig. 2A). Asp868 is also near the ion and may participate in its coordination. Together, these side chains contribute at least four oxygen atoms that can coordinate the Ca2+ ion. The Ca2+-binding site is located within a hydrophilic pocket that is large enough to accommodate additional water molecules for further coordination of the bound ion. This pocket is connected to the cytoplasmic space through a narrow path between the TRP domain and the S2-S3 linker (fig. S6, I and J). Within the pocket, Arg905 from a single 310 helical turn in S4 and Tyr790 from S1 are located above the Ca2+-binding site. In the absence of Ca2+, Arg905 is coordinated by Glu828 and Asp868 (Fig. 2B). Upon Ca2+ binding, the S2-S3 linker translates ~1.5 Å such that Tyr859 supports a tighter conformation for coordination of Ca2+ by Glu828, Gln831, Asn865, and Asp868 (fig. S6L). Furthermore, the side chain of His908 in S4 transitions from a π-π stacking arrangement with Trp864 in S3 to form a new interaction with Cys867 (Fig. 2, B and C, and fig. S6, K to N). Without coordination of Glu828 and with rearrangement in S3 and S4, Arg905 moves slightly upward (fig. S6N). The configuration of Arg905 and Tyr790 is reminiscent of a positive gating charge (arginine) and a charge-transfer center (tyrosine) observed in voltage-gated potassium channels (16). We speculate that Ca2+ binding moves Arg905 up toward Tyr790 to prime the channel for voltage-dependent opening.

A previous mutagenesis study showed that the Glu1068→Gln1068 mutation significantly reduces TRPM4 Ca2+ sensitivity (17). Glu1068 is located in the pathway leading to the Ca2+-binding site from the cytoplasmic space (fig. S6, I and J), and this mutation likely reduces the Ca2+ accessibility to the site. Of the four residues that constitute the Ca2+-binding site, Asn865 and the negative charge of Asp868 are conserved throughout the TRPM subfamily, whereas Glu828 and Gln831 as well as Tyr859 and Glu1068 are conserved only in subfamily members shown to be Ca2+ dependent: TRPM2, TRPM4, TRPM5, and TRPM8 (1820) (fig. S7). Therefore, an analogous binding site is likely present in these channels. Electrophysiological and mutagenesis studies of TRPM8 suggested that Ca2+ binds directly to an analogous site in that channel to confer sensitivity to icilin, a synthetic cooling agent. Specifically, substituting the residues corresponding to Asn865 and Asp868 results in icilin-insensitive channels that retain robust Ca2+-independent responses to cold and menthol (21).

The central pore of hTRPM4 is formed by S5 and S6 and the intervening re-entrant pore helix and pore loop. Together, these elements form an ion permeation pathway with two restriction sites, similar to other TRP channels (Fig. 3, A and B). As seen in TRPV1 (10), the outer pore is shaped as a funnel, with a negatively charged residue facing the funnel, attracting cations (fig. S8, A and B). Two highly conserved residues, Phe975 and Gly976, located in the bottom of the pore loop, form the narrowest restriction point of the upper pore. The pore diameter at this site is very similar to that of the open gate in TRPV1 (22) (Fig. 3B), which is sufficient to accommodate partially dehydrated monovalent cations. However, no density corresponding to bona fide coordinated ions is found within the pore (fig. S8, C and D). The location of a previously identified putative selectivity filter (981EDMDVA986) (23) does not coincide with this restriction site but is located further toward the extracellular face (Fig. 3C). At the bottom of the ion permeation pathway, side chains of opposing Ile1040 residues in S6 form a tight seal at the lower restriction site, signifying that both structures are in closed conformations (Fig. 3, A and B).

Fig. 3 Ion permeation pore.

(A) The solvent-accessible pathway along the ion permeation pore represented by dots between two opposing monomers shown in yellow and blue ribbons. Residues aligning the pathway are shown in sticks and labeled. (B) The pore radius of the hTRM4 EDTA (black) and CaCl2 (blue) structures overlaid with the pore radius of TRPV1 in its closed (purple) and open (orange) states. (C) Close-up view of the pore helix and pore loop. The two single-turn π helices are depicted in red in the middle of S6 and the pore helix. The putative selectivity filter is shown in orange. The inset represents the density of a bound lipid, fitted with the atomic model of CHS, which forms a tripartite complex with S1 from one monomer and the pore helix of the neighboring monomer.

The pore helix of hTRPM4 has an additional turn compared with that in other TRP channels (Fig. 3C) (913). The middle of the pore helix features a single-turn π helix (Arg964-Arg969) followed by a proline residue, Pro970, conserved in all human TRPM channels except TRPM2. Likewise, similar to what was first identified in TRPV1 (10) and subsequently observed in other TRP channels (7, 11), there is a one-turn π helix (Val1030-Leu1035) in the middle of the S6 helix (Fig. 3C). Although the exact role of these single-turn π helices is unclear, they could potentially facilitate helix bending under different functional states, leading to movement of the lower gate or modulation of the upper pore.

Outside of the pore, hTRPM4 has an extensive extracellular loop comprising more than 30 residues that connect the pore loop to the S6 helix. The loop is clearly resolved, likely stabilized by a disulfide bond between two cysteine residues (Cys993 and Cys1011) (Fig. 3C and fig. S8, F and G), a feature predicted to exist in the majority of TRPM channels. This disulfide bond is not seen in the CaCl2 structure (fig. S7H), where radiation damage may have caused disulfide bond breakage (24). The loop also contains a glycosylation site (Asn992) with the attached glycan pointing toward the extracellular space (Fig. 3C and fig. S7, G and H).

In addition to the transmembrane S1-S6 domain, hTRPM4 has distinct membrane-embedded α-helical segments (Fig. 4A). These segments surround the exterior of the S1-S4 domain within the inner leaflet of the membrane and mediate extensive interactions with the soluble domain. Preceding the S1 helix, there are two short helices shaped as an inverted “V” embedded within the inner leaflet of the membrane (Fig. 4B). We term this the “pre-S1 elbow,” similar to that observed in the mechanotransduction channel NOMPC (9). A disordered loop, unresolved in both structures, connects the pre-S1 elbow to an amphipathic helix, which we term the “pre-S1 shoulder,” positioned at the inner surface of the membrane (Fig. 4C). The pre-S1 shoulder helix contains large hydrophobic residues buried in the membrane and a number of charged residues facing the cytosol. Among these charged residues, Arg767 was identified as important for interactions with the phosphatidylinositol lipids PIP2 and PIP3 (25).

Fig. 4 Membrane-embedded helical segments surround the S1-S4 domain.

(A) Side view of the hTRPM4 monomer, with membrane-embedded helical segments labeled and in solid color. (B) The pre-S1 elbow (gold) and pre-S1 shoulder (yellow). Lipid density between the pre-S1 elbow and S1 is modeled with CHS. Side chains interacting with CHS are shown as sticks. (C) Same as (B), viewed from the opposite direction. (D) Cytoplasmic domain MHR3 interacts with the S2-S3 linker. (E) The CH1 helix after the TRP domain. Charged residues in the pre-S1 shoulder (C) and CH1 (E) are shown in sticks. Missing links are shown in dashed lines in (A) and (D).

An extended S2-S3 linker distinct to the TRPM subfamily forms a short amphipathic helix, positioned at the membrane surface, near the Ca2+-binding site (Fig. 2B). The loop that connects S2 with the S2-S3 linker is ~12 residues longer in hTRPM4 compared with other human TRPM channels and extends beyond the membrane bilayer, interacting with MHR4. Ser839 in the linker is a predicted phosphorylation site important for trafficking TRPM4 to the plasma membrane (26); however, this linker is only weakly resolved in the CaCl2 structure. In addition, the S2-S3 linker also interacts loosely with the cytoplasmic domain MHR3 (Fig. 4D).

The last segment is positioned between the pre-S1 shoulder and the S2-S3 linker helix (Fig. 4, A and F). Here, a loop fills the gap between S1 and S2 and connects the conserved TRP domain to the C-terminal helix 1 (CH1), which is located at a steep angle relative to S1, extending downward from the middle of the membrane bilayer to the cytoplasmic surface more than 20 Å away from the end of the TRP domain (Fig. 4E). The C terminus of CH1 contains five arginine residues, similar to the pre-S1 shoulder mentioned above, which likely constitute interaction partners for negatively charged lipid headgroups at the membrane interface. CH1 connects to CH2 through a 19-residue linker, which was only partially resolved in the structures and was observed to associate with MHR4 and the C-terminal end of the TRP domain.

A number of lipids were observed in our structures (fig. S9A). In addition to annular phospholipids, we identified three densities as CHS on the basis of its characteristic shape (Figs. 3C and 4B and fig. S9B). CHS is often used as a cholesterol analog (27); thus, a cholesterol molecule is likely to bind at the same sites. One CHS molecule fills a cleft at the back side of the pore, interacting with the S6 helix and the pore loop or the proposed selectivity filter of one subunit and the pore helix of the neighboring subunit. This arrangement, together with the relative rigidity of CHS over annular phospholipids, may stabilize the conformation of the pore (Fig. 3C and fig. S8E). A second CHS molecule is positioned at a location equivalent to the vanilloid binding pocket in TRPV1 (6) (fig. S9C). A third CHS is located at the pre-S1 elbow, which together with S1 and S4 creates a cavity (Fig. 4B).

Although there is no noticeable change of the pore between the two structures (Fig. 3B and fig. S10, A and C), we observe subtle yet well-defined changes in the region surrounding the Ca2+-binding site (fig. S10). In addition, CH2 is horizontally displaced by ~2.5 Å around the central coiled-coil, measured from the Cα of Glu1116, in the distal end of CH2 (fig. S10D). The rotation results in a slight tightening of the central coiled-coil (fig. S10E), likely stabilizing it, as evident by the observation that more residues in the C-terminal end of the coiled-coil were resolved in the CaCl2 structure (figs. S2G and 3G). Given that the lower gate remains closed in both structures, such conformational changes are insufficient for channel opening. However, as the extensive soluble domains are implicated in interactions with various cofactors (28), such conformational changes may be important functional features that enable the channel to better detect or responds to its cofactors (28).

Supplementary Materials

Materials and Methods

Figs. S1 to S10

Tables S1 to S3

References (2951)

References and Notes

Acknowledgments: We thank M. Diver, P. Dominik, A. Kintzer, and R. Stroud for valuable discussions; M. Diver and E. Green for reading the manuscript; and Y. Jiang for coordinating cosubmission of our studies. H.E.A. is supported by a postdoctoral fellowship from the Danish Council of Independent Research (grant DFF-5051-00085). This work was supported by grants from the NIH (R01NS047723 to D.J.; R01GM098672, S10OD020054, and S10OD021741 to Y.C.). Y.C. is an investigator of the Howard Hughes Medical Institute. Accession numbers for the human TRPM4 structures in EDTA and CaCl2, respectively, are as follows: 6BQR and 6BQV (coordinates of atomic models; Protein Data Bank), EMD-7132 and EMD-7133 (density maps; Electron Microscopy Data Bank), and EMPIAR-10126 and EMPIAR-10127 (raw particle stacks; Electron Microscopy Public Image Archive).
View Abstract

Navigate This Article