Report

Universality and Critical Behavior at the Mott Transition

See allHide authors and affiliations

Science  03 Oct 2003:
Vol. 302, Issue 5642, pp. 89-92
DOI: 10.1126/science.1088386

Abstract

We report conductivity measurements of Cr-doped V2O3 using a variable pressure technique. The critical behavior of the conductivity near the Mott insulator to metal critical endpoint is investigated in detail as a function of pressure and temperature. The critical exponents are determined, as well as the scaling function associated with the equation of state. The universal properties of a liquid-gas transition are found. This is potentially a generic description of the Mott critical endpoint in correlated electron materials.

Since the early recognition by Mott (1, 2) that electron-electron interactions are responsible for the insulating character of many transition metal oxides, extensive research over the last decade has demonstrated the key importance of this phenomenon for the physics of strongly correlated electron materials. Outstanding examples (3) are superconducting cuprates, manganites displaying colossal magnetoresistance, or fullerene compounds. There are two routes for achieving a metallic state starting from a Mott insulating material. The first is to introduce charge carriers by doping. The second, closely connected to Mott's original ideas, is to reduce the ratio U/W between the typical strength of local Coulomb repulsion (U) and the typical kinetic energy of the relevant electrons (W). This can be achieved in practice, in some materials, by selected atomic substitutions or by applying pressure. The most widely studied example (48) is Cr-doped vanadium sesquioxide (V1–x Crx)2O3, which displays a transition from a paramagnetic Mott insulator to a strongly correlated metal. The transition into the metallic state can be triggered by lowering temperature (at sufficiently small chromium concentration x), by decreasing x or by increasing pressure P [early studies (47) have revealed that decreasing concentration by Δx ∼–0.01 corresponds to an applied pressure of ΔP ∼ 4 kbar]. The transition is first-order, with a sizable reduction of the lattice spacing through the insulator-to-metal transition, indicating a coupling between electronic and lattice degrees of freedom. The first-order transition line in the (P,T)- or (x,T)-phase diagram ends in a second-order critical endpoint (Pc,Tc).

We report on transport experiments which allow for a precise identification of the critical behavior associated with this critical endpoint, a question of fundamental importance in understanding the Mott transition. Recent theoretical developments have proposed a description of the critical behavior (and also of the crossovers between distinct transport regimes close to the critical point) in simplified, purely electronic models. Despite extensive studies of this material, the critical behavior has not been elucidated so far experimentally. The key technique used here was to perform conductivity measurements as a function of continuously varying pressure, at constant temperature [see (5) for an early study]. This is particularly well adapted to the situation here in which the transition line in the (T,P) plane is very sharp. In contrast, earlier work (8) investigated conductivity as a function of temperature for a discrete set of chromium concentrations x.

We used an isopentane liquid pressure cell and controlled the value of pressure with an accuracy of 1 bar. Conductivity was measured at constant regulated temperature with an accuracy of order 0.1 K as a function of pressure using a standard four-probe method. All of our measurements were performed on crystals of (V0.989 Cr0.011)2O3 grown using the skull-melter technique followed by appropriate annealing (9). The choice of a Cr concentration x = 0.011 ensures that the sample is on the insulating side of the transition at ambient pressure but that a moderate pressure of a few kilobars (or, alternatively, a decrease in temperature) drives the system into the metallic state. This is visible on the data set (Fig. 1A), which displays the conductivity σ as a function of pressure P, for several temperatures in the range 290 K < T < 485 K. These data were obtained by decreasing pressure from P = 6 kbar down to ambient pressure, going from a high-conductivity metallic regime to a low-conductivity insulating regime. For temperatures smaller than the critical temperature Tc this transition is discontinuous, with a sudden jump of conductivity. To locate precisely this critical point and to demonstrate the first-order nature of the transition, we performed hysteresis experiments in which the conductivity was measured during increasing and decreasing pressure sweeps at a slow rate of order 25 bar/min (Fig. 1A). From the difference between the measured conductivities in these two sweeps (fig. S2), two characteristic pressures can be identified, PM(T) and PI(T) (PM < PI), corresponding to the lowest pressure at which a metallic state can be sustained while decreasing pressure (PM) and to the highest pressure at which an insulating state can be sustained while increasing pressure (PI), respectively. These two spinodal lines, plotted as a function of temperature on Fig. 1B, merge at the critical endpoint (Pc,Tc). We can then estimate that Pc ≅ 3738 bar and Tc ≅ 457.5 K. Varying pressure rather than temperature is essential for a precise determination of Tc, which is compatible with the early estimate of 450 K (8). At the critical temperature, the pressure dependence of σ(P,Tc) becomes singular, with a vertical tangent at the critical pressure P = Pc (Fig. 2A). For T > Tc, this singular behavior is replaced by a continuous variation of the conductivity with pressure, which nevertheless defines a sharp crossover line in the (P,T) phase diagram (as also depicted in Fig. 1B). This crossover line extrapolates to a temperature of order ∼500 K for the pressure (∼5 kbar) corresponding to the pure V2O3 compound. Interestingly, the location of this crossover coincides with the one detected in early nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) experiments (10).

Fig. 1.

(A) Conductivity as a function of decreasing pressure, for temperatures ranging from T = 485 K (> Tc = 457.5 K, orange curves) down to T = 290 K (< Tc, blue curves). The dark yellow curve is the conductivity at Tc. Only a selected set of values of T has been displayed for clarity. For a two-dimensional plot of the data, see fig. S1. Examples of a hysteresis cycle are shown for T = 290 K and T = 348 K. For a plot of the difference of conductivities measured in decreasing and increasing pressure sweeps, see fig. S2. Arrows indicate direction of pressure sweeps. (B) Phase diagram of Crdoped vanadium sesquioxide (V1–x Crx)2O3 as a function of pressure and temperature, in the range 1 bar < P < 6 kbar and 290 K < T < 500 K investigated here. At a given temperature T, the metallic state can be obtained for pressures higher than the spinodal pressure PM(T), and the insulating state for pressures lower than the spinodal pressure PI(T). These two spinodal lines delimit a pressure range PM < P < PI in which the two states coexist (hatched region). This coexistence region closes at the critical endpoint (Pc,Tc) (Pc ≅ 3738 bar, Tc ≅ 457.5 K). The crossover line above this point (dashed) corresponds to the inflection point in the σ(P) curves. (C) Schematic global phase diagram of Cr-doped vanadium sesquioxide (V1–x Crx)2O3 as a function of pressure and temperature, deduced from (7). These plots demonstrate how the critical exponents δ, β, and γ can be inferred from the study of the conductivity and of its derivative with respect to pressure.

Fig. 2.

(A) At the critical temperature T = Tc, the conductivity σ is plotted as a function of pressure. The bold line is a fit to σ–σc ∼ (PPc)1/δ, with δ = 3. The use of a logarithmic scale (inset) confirms this value and also reveals a non–mean-field regime for P close to Pc. (B) Order parameter σ*(T) = σ(PI(T),T)–σc versus T/Tc, for T < Tc. The line is a fit to (TcT)β with β = 0.5. The inset (logarithmic scale) reveals a non–mean-field regime close to Tc. (C) Derivative of the conductivity (analogous to a susceptibility χ, as described in text), for T < Tc and T > Tc. The plain lines are fits to χ±|TTc|–γ, with γ= 1 and χ+ = 2.

We show that the critical singularities found in the vicinity of the critical endpoint (Pc,Tc) can be analyzed in the framework of the scaling theory of the liquid-gas transition of classical systems (11). The analogy between the latter and the finite-temperature Mott transition has been emphasized earlier (5, 12). The insulating phase (in which the vanadium is mainly in the V3+ state, corresponding to the d2 configuration) can be pictured as a “gas” phase with a low density of double occupancies or holes (corresponding to V2+ and V4+, or d3 and d1, respectively). The metallic phase corresponds to a “liquid” with a sizeable density of holes and double occupancies. Recently, this analogy has been given firm theoretical foundations within the framework of a Landau theory (13, 14) derived from dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) (15). In this framework, a scalar order parameter ϕ is associated with the low-energy electronic degrees of freedom that build up the quasiparticle resonance in the strongly correlated metallic phase close to the transition. This order parameter couples to the singular part of the double occupancy (hence providing a connection to the picture described above), as well as to other observables such as the Drude weight or conductivity. Because of the scalar nature of the order parameter, the transition falls in the Ising universality class. Coupling to lattice degrees of freedom can also be included in the theory (16) without changing this conclusion. Here, we denote the scaling variable corresponding to the temperature scaling axis in the Ising model analysis (i.e., to the term rϕ2 in the Landau functional) by r and the scaling axis corresponding to magnetic field (i.e., to the symmetry-breaking term –hϕ) by h. These scaling variables are a priori linear combinations of (TTc)/Tc and (PPc)/Pc. However, our data are compatible with no or little mixing, so we choose in all the following: r = (TTc)/Tc+..., h = (PPc)/Pc +... (the dots indicate higher order terms). Denoting the measured conductivity at the critical point by σc = σ(Pc,Tc) (≅ 449.5 Ω–1cm–1), it is expected that σ(P,T) – σc depends linearly on the order parameter 〈ϕ〉 close to the critical point. (This can be explicitly proven in the context of DMFT.) At T = Tc, this implies a critical singularity of the form σ(P,Tc) – σch1/δ, with δ the critical exponent associated with the singular dependence of the magnetization at the critical point in the Ising model. The data in Fig. 2A are very well fitted by this form, as demonstrated in the inset. Over more than two decades of variation in h, we find the best fit value of the exponent to be δ ≅ 3, i.e., the mean-field value. In a narrow pressure interval (ΔP ≅ 10 bar) close to the critical pressure, indication for a crossover toward a value δ ≅ 5 is found, close to the three-dimensional (3D) Ising value δ ≅ 4.814.

We addressed the critical behavior away from Tc by studying the temperature dependence of the conductivity in the following manner. For T < Tc, we focused on the conductivity of the metallic state, at the high-pressure boundary of the coexistence region. That is, we considered σ*(T) ≡ σmet(PI(T),T) – σc with PI(T) as the spinodal of the insulating phase. This quantity (Fig. 2B) is expected to display the critical behavior of the order parameter, by analogy with the liquid-gas transition σ*(T) ∼ (–r)β, with r ∝ (TTc)/Tc. As shown in the inset, a mean-field value of the critical exponent β ≅ 0.5 is found to fit the data over almost two decades away from the critical point. In a narrow temperature interval ΔT ≅ 4 K close to TcT/Tc ≅ 0.01), some indication for a crossover towards a non–mean-field value β ≅ 0.34 is found, close to the 3D Ising value β ≅ 0.327. We also consider the derivative of the conductivity with respect to pressure, in the metallic state, taken on the same spinodal line: χ(T) ≡ (dσmet(P,T)/dP)|P = PI(T). This quantity can be defined as well for T > Tc by taking the derivative at the inflection point of the σ(P) curve (Fig. 1A). Following the liquid-gas analogy, it corresponds to the magnetic susceptibility in the equivalent Ising model: χ ∝ d〈ϕ〉/dh. As shown in Fig. 2C, it is found to diverge as χ ∼ χ+/(TTc)γ for T > Tc and as χ ∼ χ–/(TcT)γ′ for T < Tc. The exponent γ and the (universal) amplitude ratio χ+ are found to be close to their mean-field values: γ = γ′ = 1 and χ+ = 2. Very close to Tc, the noise in the numerical derivative involved in the determination of χ prevents a reliable determination of deviations from mean field, in contrast to the study of the conductivity itself.

Finally, we demonstrate that the whole set of conductivity data in the metallic phase can be scaled onto a universal form, which can be written as: Math(1) In this expression, δh = hhI denotes the difference between the “field” h = (PPc)/Pc and its value on the spinodal line of the insulating phase hI = (PIPc)/Pc, i.e., δh = (PPI(T))/Pc. This amounts to a simple shift of the field variable on the standard form (11) of the universal equation of states near a liquid-gas critical point. The functions f+ and f are universal scaling functions that apply for T > Tc (r > 0) and T < Tc (r < 0), respectively. When written in this form, the equation of state is such that the order parameter σ*(T) defined above is recovered when the limit δh→ 0 is taken in the right-hand side of Eq. 1. The pressure-dependent data sets for many different temperatures have been plotted in this manner (Fig. 3), in which the two exponents γ and δ were taken as adjustable parameters (fig. S3) in order to obtain the best collapse of all the data points onto single curves. This leads to values of these exponents close to the mean-field ones, γ ≅ 1 and δ ≅ 3, which provides a strong check on the individual determination of each critical exponent performed here. The quality of the scaling is seen to be excellent over a very large range of variation of the scaling variables (several decades). It is apparent that the scaling functions obey the expected asymptotic behaviors of f+(x ≪ 1) ∼ x1–1/δ, f(x ≪ 1) ∼ x–1/δ, and f±(x ≫ 1) ∼ constant. This finding is essential to ensure that Eq. 1 is compatible with the critical behavior of the order parameter σ* at small and large field, for both T < Tc and T > Tc, investigated previously in Fig. 2. It also implies that the critical exponents obey the relation γ = β(δ–1), in agreement with the above determination of β.

Fig. 3.

Scaling plot of the conductivity onto a universal equation of state. The whole data set in the metallic state has been used in order to plot (σ–σc)/(PPI)1/δ vs. (PPI)/(TTc)γδ/(δ–1), as described in the text. The data collapse onto two universal curves for T > Tc and T < Tc, corresponding to the universal scaling functions f± in Eq. 1.

These universal scaling properties of the pressure- and temperature-dependent conductivity experimentally demonstrate that the electronic degrees of freedom undergo a liquid-gas phase transition at the Mott critical endpoint. Critical exponents and a universal scaling function have been determined. Our results are consistent with mean-field values over most of the parameter range, with some indication for 3D Ising behavior very close to the transition. A possible explanation for why the range of validity of mean-field theory is so large can be put forward by analogy with the theory of conventional superconductors. There, the key point is the existence of a very large length scale (the pair coherence length), which is much larger than the lattice spacing (or the Fermi wavelength). Here, the Mott insulator can be thought of as a state in which holes and doubly occupied sites form bound states due to their Coulomb interaction. The spatial extension ξ of these bound states is related to their energy (the Mott gap Δ) by Δ ∼ h2/(2mξ2). Given the measured value of Δ in samples close to the transition, this leads to the conclusion that ξ is indeed a large length scale, of order a few nanometers. Finally, we emphasize that our results provide experimental support to the early idea of (12) and to recent theories of the Mott critical endpoint based on the DMFT approach (1315). Although further effort should be devoted to the inclusion of lattice degrees of freedom in these theories, simplified treatments of these effects (16) do emphasize the key role of electronic degrees of freedom in the transition.

Supporting Online Material

www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/302/5642/89/DC1

Figs. S1 to S3

References and Notes

View Abstract

Stay Connected to Science

Navigate This Article