Energy-Efficient Action Potentials in Hippocampal Mossy Fibers

See allHide authors and affiliations

Science  11 Sep 2009:
Vol. 325, Issue 5946, pp. 1405-1408
DOI: 10.1126/science.1174331


Action potentials in nonmyelinated axons are considered to contribute substantially to activity-dependent brain metabolism. Here we show that fast Na+ current decay and delayed K+ current onset during action potentials in nonmyelinated mossy fibers of the rat hippocampus minimize the overlap of their respective ion fluxes. This results in total Na+ influx and associated energy demand per action potential of only 1.3 times the theoretical minimum, in contrast to the factor of 4 used in previous energy budget calculations for neural activity. Analysis of ionic conductance parameters revealed that the properties of Na+ and K+ channels are matched to make axonal action potentials energy-efficient, minimizing their contribution to activity-dependent metabolism.

Energy expenditure due to mammalian brain activity is tightly linked to the generation and conduction of action potentials (APs), mainly in axons, and by the ensuing synaptic transmission. Estimation of the respective contributions to energy expenditure in the mammalian brain is the subject of controversy both at the cellular level (13) and at the level of non-invasive imaging methods based on local metabolic rate changes (4, 5). The clarification of these controversies is important, for example, for the interpretation of functional magnetic resonance imaging data (6, 7). However, direct experimental data to determine the energy budget of APs in gray-matter axons, which are predominantly nonmyelinated (8), have been absent.

Na+ influx during AP propagation increases Na+–K+–adenosine triphosphatase (ATPase) activity and is thus proportional to energy (ATP) consumption. Current estimates of AP costs in mammals assume that the AP requires a fourfold Na+ charge compared to the charge necessary to depolarize a pure capacitor, the theoretical minimum (13, 9, 10). The factor of 4 relies on Hodgkin′s notion (11), derived from the analysis of squid giant axons, showing that inward Na+ and outward K+ currents overlap extensively during simulated APs (12), wasting Na+ and accordingly energy. Early data on nonmyelinated axons of different species obtained with radiolabeled K+, however, cast doubt on the general applicability of Hodgkin′s notion (13).

To experimentally investigate the energetics of axonal APs in the mammalian cortex, it is essential to measure, at physiological temperatures, the ion fluxes underlying axonal APs, which differ from somatic APs (14, 15), as might the underlying currents (16, 17). Patch-clamp recordings at 36° to 37°C from rat hippocampal mossy fiber boutons (MFBs, Fig. 1A) (14, 18), which are presynaptic expansions of nonmyelinated mossy fibers (19), revealed brief APs (249 ± 4 μs half-duration, n = 14; Fig. 1A and fig. S1), resembling neocortical axonal APs (15). Ionic currents underlying the AP were determined by applying a previously recorded AP wave (Fig. 1B, black trace) as a voltage command (20) to outside-out patches from MFBs. Na+ currents (INa) showed rapid activation and fast decay (decay time constants = 24 ± 3 μs, 0.80 ± 0.03 amplitude contribution; and 130 ± 12 μs, 0.20 ± 0.03 amplitude contribution; Fig. 1, B and C, red traces; fig. S1, n = 8). The onset of K+ currents (IK; Fig. 1, B and C, blue traces; n = 8) was significantly delayed compared to that of INa (106 ± 5 μs; P < 0.001), similar to results obtained from whole-bouton recordings (Fig. 1D, 115 ± 7 μs; P < 0.001, n = 8; P > 0.5 for patch versus whole-bouton recording). The resulting small overlap of inward and outward currents [Fig. 1, B (inset) and C] indicated a high Na+ efficiency and, accordingly, energy efficiency in hippocampal mossy fibers, contrasting with previous simulations of axonal APs and their underlying currents (12, 17, 21).

Fig. 1

Temporal separation of transmembrane currents during the MFB AP at 36° to 37°C. (A) (Top) Sketch of a hippocampal granule cell (mossy fiber truncated). (Middle) Fluorescence image of a hippocampal mossy fiber with presynaptic expansions (MFBs and filopodial extensions). (Bottom) MFB-APs from different experiments. (B) Upper trace, MFB-AP as voltage command to outside-out patches of MFBs. Middle trace, isolated INa (in 1 mM 4-AP). Bottom trace, isolated IK (in 1 μM TTX). Recordings were made from different patches. The inset defines the measure of charge separation: Na+ charge that is not counterbalanced by simultaneously flowing K+ charge divided by total Na+ charge per AP. (C) Average INa of different experiments inverted and overlaid on average IK of different experiments (scaled to the mean amplitude of all INa or IK, respectively), indicating the experimental range of current kinetics across patches. (D) Relative timing of INa onset, IK onset, and the presynaptic ICa (in TTX and 4-AP) in response to the MFB-AP wave (without prepulse) recorded in the whole-bouton configuration. Recordings were made from different MFBs. (Inset) Whole-bouton INa and IK, scaled to the respective mean of the amplitudes of all whole-bouton INa or IK experiments.

To complement these results by a quantitative assessment of the Na+ influx as well as peak Na+and K+ conductance densities (GNa and GK) underlying an AP propagating along an axon, we performed numerical simulations of APs. We used conductance functions (Fig. 2A) derived from recorded currents (Fig. 1) in a compartmental model of the mossy fiber (18) to reconstitute propagating APs (22). Simulations resulted in AP waveforms and underlying currents closely resembling recorded APs and currents (Fig. 2B and fig. S1, A to D). The validity of our approach was further tested with independent predictions of the model, such as INa onset potential and AP propagation velocity, which both complied with experimental data (Fig. 2C and fig. S2). The charge separation, measured as the ratio of nonoverlapping to total Na+ charge per AP (Fig. 1B, inset), amounted to 0.79 ± 0.03 in the simulations (n = 8), consistent with a value of 0.80 ± 0.02 obtained from patch data (n = 8; Fig. 2, B and D) (22). The resulting mean value of GNa peak amplitudes was 39 ± 3 mS/cm2, in good agreement with previous results (16), and that of GK peak amplitudes was 7.8 ± 0.3 mS/cm2 (n = 8,respectively). The mean Na+ charge transfer per propagating AP was 153 ± 6 nC/cm2 (n = 8), being only 1.3 times the theoretical minimum (Fig. 2E; n = 8) of 121 nC/cm2 for a target AP amplitude of 121 mV [specific membrane capacitance (Cm) 1 μF/cm2], which is considerably less than the factor of 4 used in the literature (13, 9, 10). The corresponding 1.6 ± 0.1 pmol of Na+ ions/cm2 per AP is close to earlier estimates for nonmyelinated axons of diverse species but not to data from the squid giant axon (13), causing an absolute energy demand per AP of ~ 0.53 ± 0.02 pmol of ATP/cm2 [assuming that the Na+-K+-ATPase transports three Na+ ions per ATP molecule; for comparison to the costs of preserving a resting membrane potential of –80 mV and an estimate of the required Na+-K+-ATPase density, see (22)]. Thus, the energy expenditure associated with mossy fiber APs themselves is only about one-third of that hitherto assigned to nonmyelinated axons of the mammalian brain (1, 3, 10).

Fig. 2

Reconstitution modeling of recorded APs reveals close to minimum Na+ charge transfer during propagating APs. (A) (Top) Schematic mossy fiber (mf). Curr. inj., current injection site in current-clamp simulation. (Bottom) Experimentally derived, normalized Na, K, and Ca conductance time courses from current measurements in Fig. 1B (INa and IK) and Fig. 1D (ICa). (B) (Top) MFB-AP from current clamp simulation (green) superimposed on the recorded target MFB-AP of Fig. 1B (black). (Middle) Peak conductance densities obtained from fit. (Bottom) Currents underlying the simulated AP, superimposed on the recorded currents (black) of Fig. 1B (INa and IK) and Fig. 1D (ICa). (C) (Top) Comparison of the range of Na+ current onset potentials in simulations and patch experiments. (Bottom) AP conduction velocities in simulations compared to experimentally determined velocities (at 36° to 37°C). (D) Charge separation as defined in Fig. 1B, inset, in simulations and patch experiments. (E) Costs of a propagating AP in simulations expressed as Na+ charge transfer per AP relative to the theoretical minimum of charging a pure capacitor to a voltage difference equaling the AP amplitude. Circles indicate individual simulations; the cross indicates the mean ± SEM (error bars indicate SEM).

How critical are conductance parameters such as GNa decay time and GK onset delay in determining the energy efficiency of mossy fiber APs? The AP reconstitution approach constrained by recorded target APs enabled us to systematically analyze the dependence of Na+ influx per AP on different combinations of the two modified conductance parameters. In the majority of combinations (20 out of 25), the amplitude, half-duration, and propagation velocity of simulated APs were consistent with those of recorded APs [Fig. 3, A and D (yellow and purple circles)]. These APs represented functionally equivalent signals with respect to information transmission but differed considerably with respect to underlying currents and the Na+ charge relative to the theoretical minimum (Fig. 3E, yellow and purple bars), ranging from 1.1 to 3.2. The results were reproduced in a cylindrical axon, indicating independence of morphology, axon diameter, and basic electrophysiological properties (figs. S3 and S4). We also obtained APs that slightly failed to reach either the amplitude or the half-duration of recorded APs (Fig. 3, B to E, gray circles and bars). Among these, the energetically most expensive combination (Fig. 3B) was reminiscent of Hodgkin and Huxley’s simulated currents underlying the AP and associated deviations of the simulated from the recorded APs of the squid giant axon (12). Conductance combinations that matched experimentally derived GNa decay times and GK onset delays and that resulted in AP shapes consistent with recordings were among those which displayed a minimized Na+ charge cost (Fig. 3E, yellow bars).

Fig. 3

Experimentally revealed conductance properties optimize AP-related Na+ charge transfer and thus energy demand in simulations. (A) Gray traces indicate modifications of the normalized GNa and GK time courses of Fig. 2A; first number, GNa decay time (peak to zero amplitude; in milliseconds); second number, GK onset delay (in milliseconds) from GNa onset. Colored traces, resulting INa (red) and IK (blue), superimposed on the resulting simulated AP (green). (B) Example of a simulation in which the parameter combination resulted in a poor reconstitution of the recorded target AP. (C) Overlay of the simulated APs of (A) and (B) [on a different time scale than in (A) and (B)]. (D) Distribution of AP amplitude and half-duration of recorded APs (Expt., squares) and of simulated APs (Sim., circles). Black squares indicate target APs used for the fits in Fig. 3, D to F. (E) AP cost expressed as Na+ charge transfer per AP relative to the theoretical minimum for different combinations of ionic conductance parameters. The color code indicates the level of match between simulations and experiments with respect to conductance parameters (chosen for the simulation) and AP (amplitude and half-duration; simulation result). (F) Best-fit, AP wave–evoked peak GNa and GK densities of the simulations in (D) and (E). Numbers in parentheses indicate the ionic conductance parameter combination. Error bars indicate SEM.

In addition, the fit results for the different conductance parameter combinations in Fig. 3E also varied with respect to GNa and GK peak amplitudes. Conductance parameter combinations containing a fast GNa decay and long GK onset delay as observed experimentally result in comparatively low GNa and GK peak amplitudes (Fig. 3F, yellow circles). Thus, the observed degrees of charge separation are accompanied by comparatively low peak conductance densities, suggesting low numbers of channel proteins per area, which would minimize infrastructural costs for AP conduction. Taken together, both the fast decay of GNa and the precisely matched delay of GK onset at the mossy fiber optimize the energy efficiency of axonal APs. AP amplitude, shape, and propagation velocity were rather insensitive to a variety of combinations of conductance parameters, which implies that physiological descriptions of APs require the reconstitution not only of APs but also of underlying currents.

To relate the costs of APs themselves as determined above to downstream costs in the hippocampal mossy fiber system, we analyzed the presynaptic Ca2+ influx (Figs. 1D and 2B) and the inward charge transfer mediated by unitary AMPA receptor–mediated excitatory currents in different postsynaptic neuron types (Fig. 4, A and B) (18, 23). From these data, we calculated that the cost ratio of the mossy fiber AP itself to the downstream events (Fig. 4) has an upper limit of about 0.15 (22), shifting the emphasis of activity-dependent energy demand to downstream processes elicited by transmitter release, as suggested by in vivo work (4, 6, 7).

Fig. 4

The charge transfer related to synaptic transmission in the hippocampal mossy fiber system is considerably larger than that for APs. (A) Schematic diagram of the hippocampal mossy fiber system. GC, granule cell; PN, principal neuron (light blue); IN, interneuron (dark blue); fil. ext., filopodial extensions; bout., boutons. (B) Examples of unitary AMPA receptor–mediated currents (black) at two types of output synapses and the average charge transfer per contact (blue shaded areas; GC-CA3 pyramidal neuron synapse and GC-dentate gyrus basket cell synapse). (C) Summary of the respective total charge transfers related to propagation of a single mossy fiber AP (left bar), ensuing presynaptic Ca2+ entry (right bar, purple) and postsynaptic cation inflow (right bar, blue) in response to the mossy fiber AP, mediated by ligand-gated glutamate receptors in PNs (light blue) and INs (dark blue).

Assuming a widespread occurrence of a high degree of charge separation during APs in axons, our results could resolve disparities between systemic in vivo studies (4, 6, 7) and bottom-up energy budget calculations (13). Our findings challenge the general applicability of Hodgkin′s notion (13, 9, 10) to gray-matter nonmyelinated axons but are in line with considerations that in evolution, the economy of neural processes tends to be optimized (24).

Supporting Online Material

Materials and Methods

Figs. S1 to S4


  • * Present address: Institute of Neurophysiology, Neuroscience Research Center, Charité-Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Charitéplatz 1, 10117 Berlin, Germany.

References and Notes

  1. Materials and methods are available as supporting material on Science Online.
  2. We thank A. Lampert and C. Schmidt-Hieber for discussion on sodium conductances and M. Häusser for comments on the manuscript. This work was supported by the Max Planck Society, the Hertie Foundation, the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (AL 1193/2-1), and the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council.
View Abstract

Navigate This Article