Report

Transnuclear Mice with Predefined T Cell Receptor Specificities Against Toxoplasma gondii Obtained via SCNT

See allHide authors and affiliations

Science  09 Apr 2010:
Vol. 328, Issue 5975, pp. 243-248
DOI: 10.1126/science.1178590

Abstract

Mice that are transgenic for rearranged antigen-specific T cell receptors (TCRs) are essential tools to study T cell development and function. Such TCRs are usually isolated from the relevant T cells after long-term culture, often after repeated antigen stimulation, which unavoidably skews the T cell population used. Random genomic integration of the TCR α and β chain and expression from nonendogenous promoters represent additional drawbacks of transgenics. Using epigenetic reprogramming via somatic cell nuclear transfer, we demonstrated that T cells with predefined specificities against Toxoplasma gondii can be used to generate mouse models that express the TCR from their endogenous loci, without experimentally introduced genetic modification. The relative ease and speed with which such transnuclear models can be obtained holds promise for the construction of other disease models.

The resolution of an infectious disease requires careful orchestration of innate and adaptive immunity. B and T cells specific for infectious agents are not easily obtained in abundant and pure form, yet their availability is crucial in defining their activation requirements and protective properties, either as a single clone or as an ensemble of different specificities. During the peak of an immune response, as many as 30% of all CD8+ T cells may be pathogen-specific (1, 2). For viral pathogens such as vaccinia virus or mouse herpes virus-68, several dozen antigens may be recognized by CD8+ and CD4+ T cells (35). Existing T cell receptor (TCR) transgenic mouse models have all been constructed from T-cell clones or hybridomas selected for survival and response to antigens in vitro. Whether these transgenic mouse models accurately reflect the affinities and activation requirements of lymphocytes triggered during a physiological response to an infection is not known.

Somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) allows the generation of embryonic stem cells (ESCs) and mice from any somatic cell through epigenetic reprogramming without the introduction of genetic modifications (68). The specificity of TCRs or B cell receptors (BCRs) is determined by site-specific recombination of their V, D, and J gene segments. Consequently, when SCNT is applied to lymphocytes of known specificity, these genetic V(D)J rearrangements are transferred to the SCNT-ESCs and the mice derived from them, whereas epigenetic marks are reset (Fig. 1A). Natural killer T cells (NKTs) carrying an invariant TCR, as well as T and B cells of unknown specificity, have been used as donor cells for SCNT, demonstrating that mice can be cloned from such cells and that their rearranged TCR- or Ig-loci can be transmitted through the germline (912).

Fig. 1

SCNT of predefined T cells. (A) Schematic representation of the underlying strategy and timeline. (B) Absolute and relative numbers of SCNT performed with CD8+ T cells and derived ESCs in B6CF1 background. (C) (Top) Representative flow cytometry plots of B6CF1 background mice infected with T. gondii. Gate and number (percent per total CD8+ T cells) indicates sorted CD8+ T cells with defined specificity used as donor cells. (Bottom) Representative flow cytometry analysis of chimeric mice injected with SCNT-ESCs derived from corresponding donor cells in top panels. Gate and number (percent per total CD8+ T cells) indicates the presence of specific CD8+ T cells in chimeric mice.

We applied this approach to create a new mouse model by using effector CD8+ T cells specific for Toxoplasma gondii, isolated at the height of resolving an acute infection (13). We focused on these cells because protective immunity against this protozoan critically depends on interferon (IFN)–γ produced by CD8+ T cells (14, 15). We had identified two naturally processed epitopes, Ld-Tg-Rop7161-169 (R7) and Ld-Tg-Gra4107-115 (G4), restricted by the major histocompatibility complex antigen (MHC-I) H-2Ld and recognized by CD8+ T cells (16). Using a similar approach, a screen for epitopes recognized by H-2Kb or H-2Db led to the identification of one H-2b–restricted epitope, Kb-Tg-tgd05759-66 (T57), a protein of unknown function (17). One additional H-2d epitope, Ld-Tg-Gra6215-224, was identified in parallel (18). However, there has been no mouse model that provides access to naïve antigen-inexperienced T. gondii–specific T cells.

A Look at the Method

Science is working with the Journal of Visualized Experiments to provide online videos documenting methods underlying selected papers. In this video, author Oktay Kirak demonstrates SCNT and other techniques used in the current study.

Have comments on this feature? Please let us know in a quick online survey.

We used CD8+ T cells specific for R7, G4, and T57 on the BL/6 x Balb/c F1 (B6CF1) background as donor cells for SCNT, a procedure that is more efficient for donor nuclei of mixed background (6). To improve nuclear reprogramming, we made use of trichostatin A (TSA), an inhibitor of histone deacetylases (Fig. 1B). We generated SCNT-blastocysts with an overall efficiency of 7.2% per pseudo-pronucleus (PPN) in all three conditions and obtained ESCs when using TSA treatment for 6 hours (four ESC lines) or 10 hours (one ESC line), but none in the absence of TSA. As a control, fertilized blastocysts on the B6CF1 background yielded 47 ESCs per 48 blastocysts (fig. S1A). When CD8+ T cells from a pure Balb/c background were used as donor cells, we derived two SCNT-ESC lines with similar efficiency (fig. S1B), but only after 10 hours of TSA treatment, confirming reports that TSA indeed facilitates cloning of inbred mice (7, 19).

We generated chimeric mice using the five SCNT-ESC lines from the B6CF1 background, all of which showed pronounced populations of tetramer-positive CD8+ T cells in the absence of infection with T. gondii (Fig. 1C). Chimeric mice derived from the two SCNT-ESC lines on the Balb/c background also yielded CD8+ T cells of correct specificity (fig. S1C). We thus cloned T cells of desired specificity in seven out of seven cases, a rate that depends on both TSA treatment and the ability to obtain donor cells of sufficient purity. We refer to these animals as transnuclear (TN) mice because such mice, generated via SCNT of T cells (or B cells) with preselected specificity, represent a new type of mouse model.

To test for germline transmission and to establish TN mouse lines, chimeric mice with T57 T cells (H-2b–restricted) were backcrossed onto the MHC-matched BL/6 background. Offspring with agouti coat color indicated germline transmission (fig. S1D). Chimeric mice with H-2d–restricted T cells (G4 and R7) were backcrossed onto the MHC-matched Balb/c background, and offspring with a white coat color indicated germline transmission (fig. S1D). All litters from transmitting males were analyzed by means of either polymerase chain reaction (PCR) or flow cytometry in order to identify offspring carrying the corresponding TCR (fig. S1, E to G). We secured germline transmission of the respective TCRs in five out of five SCNT-ESC lines derived from the B6CF1 background. No germline transmission was achieved for the two SCNT-ESC lines from the Balb/c background. The resulting animals represented three different TCR specificities (T57, G4, and R7), restricted by two different MHC-I alleles (H-2Ld and H-2Kb).

We next identified the genomic TCR rearrangements from the TN mice on the B6CF1 background (Fig. 2A and fig. S2, A and B) by means of rapid amplification of cDNA ends (RACE)–PCR. Examination of the cDNA sequences obtained showed that the three SCNT-ESC lines specific for R7 were different from each other. A comparison of their amino acid sequences revealed no obvious pattern of the complementary determining region 3 (CDR3) that would explain their shared specificity (fig. S2C).

Fig. 2

TCR sequence and comparison of TN T cells with wild-type and transgenic mice. (A) Schematic representation of the V(D)J rearrangements at the TCR-α (top) and TCR-β locus (bottom) in TN mice. Top row represents wild-type configuration and some regions for orientation (data are based on www.ensembl.org). (B and C) Representative flow cytometric analysis of splenocytes from (B) wild-type, T57, and OT-I mice or (C) wild-type, G4, and 2C Rag−/− mice (two mice per genotype were analyzed).

To characterize TN mice, we compared splenocytes from the T57 line with B6CF1 wild-type mice and a widely used TCR transgenic line also restricted by H-2Kb, OT-I, which is specific for a chicken ovalbumin–derived peptide (SIINFEKL) (20). A comparison of T cells (CD3+) and B cells (B220+) showed that the TN line had a relative increase in the CD3+ population (35.6% for TN versus 12.8% for B6CF1 wild type) and that this population consisted mainly of CD8+ T cells (91.3% for TN versus 43.1% for wild type) (Fig. 2B). A skewing in the CD8+ population was also apparent in the OT-I line (84.8%), but without a relative increase in CD3+ cells (17.7%). The majority of CD8+ TN cells were CD44low CD62L+, which is indicative of a naïve phenotype (64.1% for T57 versus 69.6% for wild type). We also compared the TN line G4 to the transgenic line 2C (Fig. 2C). The alloreactive 2C line was derived from a Balb/b mouse (H-2b) injected with H-2d cells (H-2b anti H-2d). Its response against the QL9 peptide is particularly well-characterized (2123). Similar patterns were observed for the two TN lines G4 and T57. TN mice expressing only a single copy of a pre-rearranged endogenous β-chain had no major changes in T cell subsets, whereas TN mice expressing a single copy of a pre-rearranged endogenous α-chain had an increase in CD3+ CD4 CD8 cells in the spleen (fig. S3, A and B). Finally, we found that T-cell development in TN mice T57 and G4 in all aspects examined resembles that of B6CF1 wild-type mice and of some transgenic lines (fig. S4, A to D, and fig. S5, A and B).

Because TN CD8+ T cells were generated from freshly isolated effector CD8+ T cells, we hypothesized that TN T cells may have MHC-binding characteristics that are distinct from conventional TCR transgenic mice. In a MHC-I–tetramer dissociation assay, the TN CD8+ T cells of H-2Ld haplotype dissociated faster from their cognate peptide–MHC-I complex than did transgenic 2C cells (Fig. 3A). The observed differences in dissociation rate of the H-2Ld T cells are not due to differences in peptide-MHC interactions because the peptides QL9, G4, and R7 stabilized H-2Ld in transporter of antigen processing (TAP)–deficient cells equally well (Fig. 3B). Although we are aware of the limitations of tetramer dissociation as a surrogate parameter for TCR affinity (24), we consider it possible that the average T. gondii–specific H-2Ld–restricted TCR may well be of lower affinity than the highly selected 2C. A comparison of TN T57 with transgenic OT-I cells showed similar dissociation rates (Fig. 3C). We examined the ability of TN CD8+ T cells to produce IFN-γ upon stimulation with peptide-loaded antigen-presenting cells in vitro. TN T cells secreted IFN-γ only when stimulated with the corresponding peptide (Fig. 3D).

Fig. 3

TN T cell function in vitro. (A) Dissociation of peptide-Ld tetramers from CD8+ T cells was measured for the transgenic line 2C Rag−/− (Ld-QL9) and the TN lines R7 I-III and G4 by use of flow cytometry and plotted over time. Number of repeats (n) is shown in brackets. Data plotted represents mean ± SEM. (B) Stabilization of H-2Ld on the surface of TAP-deficient cells via titration of QL9, R7, or G4 peptide [analyzed by use of GraphPad Prism software (GraphPad Software, La Jolla, CA)]. (C) Dissociation of the peptide-Kb tetramers from CD8+ T cells for the transgenic line OT-I and the TN line T57. Number of repeats (n) is shown in brackets. Data plotted is mean ± SEM. (D) Flow cytometry analysis of IFN-γ secretion upon stimulation of TN T cells with antigen-presenting cells loaded with control peptide (top) or corresponding specific peptide (bottom).

To assess the extent to which the presence of only the TCR α- or β-chain suffices to yield TCRs of specificity similar to that of the TN αβ pair, we analyzed mice that carry only the TN α- or only the TN β-chain of T57 or G4 (fig. S6A). There was no increase in tetramer-positive T cells in mice carrying the TN β-chain or α-chain only.

We next compared the in vivo response of wild-type BL/6 and TN CD8+ T cells to an infection with T. gondii (Fig. 4, A and B, and fig. S6, B to E). In wild-type mice, we detected T57 tetramer-positive CD8+ T cells mainly between day 9 to 15 after infection, with a maximum frequency of about 7% (fig. S6B). When T57 CD8+ T cells were adoptively transferred into wild-type mice, the kinetics of expansion were comparable but with a much higher frequency of T57 tetramer-positive CD8+ TN T cells (about 60%) (Fig. 4, A and B). We detected little or no response from the endogenous CD8+ T cells in these mice that received TN T cells (Fig. 4A and fig. S6C). Similarly, when carboxyfluorescein diacetate succinimidyl ester (CFSE)–labeled CD8+ T cells from wild-type or T57 mice were transferred into recipient mice which were then infected with T. gondii, up-regulation of CD69 and dilution of CFSE was observed only in mice receiving T57 T cells (fig. S6, D and E).

Fig. 4

TN T57 T-cell function in vivo. (A) In vivo response of wild-type BL/6 mice having received an adoptive transfer of TN T57 CD8+ cells (three mice per time point per group). Representative flow cytometric analysis at different time points after infection, with the boxes showing the percentage of T57-specific cells among CD8+ T cells, are shown. TN cells (red boxes) and endogenous cells (blue boxes) can be distinguished by use of CD90.2. (B) Graphical representation of the flow cytometric results showing the kinetics of wild-type (black curve) and TN (red curve) T57-specific CD8+ T cells (analyzed by use of GraphPad Prism software). (C) Survival curve of wild-type B6CF1 mice infected with lethal dose of tachyzoites (n = 7 mice for each group). (D) Optical imaging of luciferase-expressing T. gondii during a lethal challenge (left) and quantification of signal (right) (n = 4 mice per group). Data plotted are mean ± SEM. Triple asterisk indicates significant difference (two-way analysis of variance, P < 0.001).

We next investigated the protective potential of CD8+ T cells from T57 TN mice. Animals infected with a lethal dose of T. gondii die around day 10, and some of the CD8+ T-cell responses do not peak before that time (1618). When B6CF1 mice were challenged with a lethal dose of T. gondii, four out of seven mice receiving CD8+ T cells from T57 TN mice survived the acute phase of infection, as compared with one out of seven in the control group (Fig. 4C). Using live imaging in the course of a lethal challenge with luciferase-expressing T. gondii, we observed a significant reduction in parasite load at day 7 after infection in the group that received CD8+ T cells from T57 (Fig. 4D). Further experiments will show whether all five TN lines are equally capable of controlling T. gondii and help establish the number of specific cells needed, as well as the cell type (naïve, effector, or memory T cell) that is most effective at protection.

Transgenic mouse models have long been used to study various aspects of the immune system. Their generation involves long-term culture and repeated stimulation of T cells with antigen, isolation of the TCR α- and β-chains as cDNA or genomic fragments under the control of a non-endogenous promoter, and integration of the TCR into the mouse genome at non-homologous sites (2527). This inevitably leads to variation in expression levels, kinetics, and development even in mice expressing the same TCR (28). Further studies of suitable TCR transgenic lines are governed mostly by random selection of a “best responder.” To show that somatic cells can be reprogrammed, a mouse line had been generated from a randomly chosen T cell (10). This mouse showed skewed T-cell development, with a strong increase in the CD4-CD8 DN population (45% in LN3 compared to 5% in wild type), attributed to aberrant expression of the α-chain (11). Besides a relative shift in the DN1-4 stages toward the DN4 phase, we did not observe an increase in the CD4-CD8 DN population in the TN mice reported here. TN mice have no additional experimentally introduced genetic modifications. Consequently, the differences observed amongst TN lines must be due to position effects within the rearranged TCR locus or derive from the intrinsic properties of the expressed TCR. A comparison of different TN mouse lines might therefore allow a detailed dissection of these properties without the confounding effects of transgenic artifacts.

The time-consuming generation of transgenic mouse models has led to the widespread use of a limited number of surrogate antigens, such as ovalbumin (recognized by the OT-I and OT-II transgenic mice) to study the immunobiology of infectious disease. Pathogens engineered to produce fragments of ovalbumin, and the immune reaction against it, are unlikely to capture all essential aspects of the physiological response. As an example, we show that T57 TN CD8+ T cells proliferate upon infection with T. gondii and significantly reduce the parasite-burden but provide limited protection against an acute lethal challenge with T. gondii. Are responses against all epitopes equally protective? What is the best cell type to provide protection? Do responses against some epitopes protect from Toxoplasma-induced encephalitis? The answers to such questions require ready access to T cells that accurately reflect the natural response against the pathogen, and TN T cells arguably meet these requirements best. Taken together, TN mice obtained by means of SCNT can be generated rapidly from freshly isolated specific CD8+ T cells. As long as methods for identification of antigen-specific lymphocytes can be applied, this strategy should also be applicable for CD4+ T cells and B cells. TN mice resemble a new type of mouse model that express their TCR α- and β-chains from their endogenous loci under the control of their endogenous promoters without further genetic modification, thus avoiding genetic footprints at the site of integration, which is an unavoidable hallmark of transgenics.

Supporting Online Material

www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/328/5975/243/DC1

Materials and Methods

Figs. S1 to S6

References

  • Current address: Immunology Programme and Departments of Microbiology and Biological Sciences, National University of Singapore, 117456 Singapore.

References and Notes

  1. Materials and methods are available as supporting material on Science Online.
  2. The authors are thankful to H. Eisen, M. J. Gubbels, K. van Grinsven, E. Guillen, A. Drake, V. Mahajan, Q. Gao, and G. Yap for fruitful discussions and reagents; J. Dausman, R. Flannery, and J. Jackson for assistance with the management of the mouse colony; P. Wisniewski for FACSorting; and J. Saeij and K. Jensen for the Pru PA7 and assistance with the in vivo imaging. E.M.F. was supported by the Human Frontiers Science Program. R.J. was supported by NIH grants RO1-HD045022 and R37-CA084198. H.L.P. was supported by grants from NIH. We thank L. Clay for financial support. The Whitehead Institute has filed a patent related to the generation of mice with defined antigen receptor specificity using epigenetic reprogramming (international patent application PCT/US2009/049596). The sequences have been submitted to the European Molecular Biology Laboratory Nucleotide Sequence Database, accession number FN601337-FN601346.
View Abstract

Navigate This Article