Interstitial Dendritic Cell Guidance by Haptotactic Chemokine Gradients

See allHide authors and affiliations

Science  18 Jan 2013:
Vol. 339, Issue 6117, pp. 328-332
DOI: 10.1126/science.1228456


Directional guidance of cells via gradients of chemokines is considered crucial for embryonic development, cancer dissemination, and immune responses. Nevertheless, the concept still lacks direct experimental confirmation in vivo. Here, we identify endogenous gradients of the chemokine CCL21 within mouse skin and show that they guide dendritic cells toward lymphatic vessels. Quantitative imaging reveals depots of CCL21 within lymphatic endothelial cells and steeply decaying gradients within the perilymphatic interstitium. These gradients match the migratory patterns of the dendritic cells, which directionally approach vessels from a distance of up to 90-micrometers. Interstitial CCL21 is immobilized to heparan sulfates, and its experimental delocalization or swamping the endogenous gradients abolishes directed migration. These findings functionally establish the concept of haptotaxis, directed migration along immobilized gradients, in tissues.

Several guidance cues operate in vertebrates, with the most prominent group being chemokines. In vitro, many chemokines induce directional cell migration when offered as gradients. However, the best established in vivo example of chemokine function does not rely on gradients: During extravasation from the blood stream, chemokines immobilized on the luminal surface of blood vessels (13) trigger the local arrest of leukocytes, which precedes their exit into the tissue (4). Less is known about how chemokines act beyond the endothelium (5), and, especially within lymphatic organs, chemokines seem to rather cause random motility than directional responses (5). The sparse body of existing evidence for directional guidance is largely inferred from the migratory trajectories of cells without information on actual chemokine distribution (68). Only two studies visualized chemokine gradients in parenchymal organs (9, 10), and the concept that gradients trigger directional migration has not been addressed with manipulative approaches.

We used mature dendritic cells (DCs) that migrate from the dermal interstitium into afferent lymphatic vessels (LVs) (11) as a model system to study chemokine function in situ. To track DCs en route to LVs, we used tissue explants of split mouse ears (12). Within minutes after addition of exogenous DCs onto exposed dermal tissue, the cells entered the interstitium and approached nearby LVs in a directed manner (Fig. 1, A to D, and movie S1). Single-cell tracking within the almost-planar anatomy of the mouse ear (fig. S1) revealed that cells switched from nondirectional to increasingly directional persistent movement toward the vessel at a distance of about 90 μm from the vessel wall (Fig. 1, B to D, and fig. S2). When located between two LVs, DCs occasionally extended protrusions toward both vessels, indicating the simultaneous presence of two conflicting signals. There the cells often spanned distances of more than 50 μm before they retracted one protrusion and finally entered one of the vessels (Fig. 1E and movie S2). In line with previous studies (13), DCs deficient for the chemokine receptor CCR7 did not approach LVs. CCR7 dependency was cell-autonomous, because the presence of comigrating wild-type DCs could not rescue CCR7-deficient cells (Fig. 1F). Hence, the involvement of secondarily induced paracrine guidance cues that might relay the directional information was excluded. CCR7 has two ligands, CCL19 and CCL21. By using tissues and DCs from CCL19-deficient animals (14), we found, in agreement with an earlier report (15), that CCL19 was not required for intravasation into afferent LVs (fig. S3).

Fig. 1

DCs move directionally toward CCL21-expressing LVs in the dermal interstitium. (A to D) Tracks of DCs migrating in ear explants. (A) Migratory paths (lines in gray) tracked from a representative 60-min movie, overlaid onto the LV mask (dark gray). (B) Selected tracks (gray) from five movies (n = 200, three independent experiments) reorientated to nearest LV (LV margin at distance = 0 indicated by the black horizontal line). (C and D) Directionality and velocity toward LV as a function of distance to the nearest LV. Mean ± SEM is shown. n = 200, three independent experiments. a.u., arbitrary units. (E) Wild-type DC (highlighted by the white arrow) migrating between two adjacent vessels (indicated by yellow dotted lines). Scale bar indicates 50 μm. (F) (Left) Z-stack projection showing wild-type (red) and Ccr7−/− DCs (green) after 120-min incubation with ear sheets stained for LYVE-1 (blue). Scale bar, 100 μm. (Right) DC migration paths tracked from a representative 60-min movie, overlaid onto the LV mask (dark gray).

We therefore measured the localization of the other CCR7 ligand, CCL21, within the dermis. Whole-mount immunostainings of ear sheets that were previously fixed and permeabilized revealed a punctuate CCL21 staining that was exclusively associated with LVs as revealed by lymphatic vessel endothelial hyaluronan receptor 1 (LYVE-1) and basement membrane stainings (Fig. 2, A and B). Disrupting the trans-Golgi network by tissue treatment with brefeldin A led to loss of the punctuate pattern and to scattering of CCL21 within individual LYVE-1–bordered (16) lymphatic endothelial cells (Fig. 2B). This suggests that the main source of CCL21 production is lymphatic endothelium, which harbors intracellular depots of this chemokine. Because intracellular CCL21 is not available for cells, especially when located at a distance from the vessel, we used unfixed, nonpermeabilized tissues to exclusively detect extracellular chemokine. The punctuate pattern was not detected. Although the signals were considerably lower than in the permeabilized tissue, the interstitial distribution of CCL21 became apparent: CCL21 peaked on the vessel wall and appeared to gradually fade with increasing distance from the vessel (Fig. 2C).

Fig. 2

Visualization and quantification of an interstitial CCL21 gradient. (A) Z-stack projection of permeabilized ear dermis stained for CCL21 (red) and laminin (green). Scale bar, 100 μm. (B) CCL21 (green) LYVE-1+ (red) co-staining of permeabilized ear dermis after treatment with 25 μg/ml brefeldin A. Scale bar, 25 μm. (C) Z-stack projection of nonpermeabilized ear dermis stained for CCL21. Gray scale shows maximum intensity projection (left). Right image shows same staining as color-coded average projection. LV boundaries are indicated by the blue dotted line based on LYVE-1 staining (as shown in fig. S2). Scale bars, 100 μm. A representative image from n = 9 out of four independent experiments is shown. (D) Quantification of interstitial CCL21 and CCL19 staining as function of distance from the nearest LV margin. Mean signal intensities relative to average maximum CCL21 signal ± SEM are shown (red, CCL21; green, CCL19 in Ccl19+/+ ear; n = 9; four independent experiments; black, CCL19 in Ccl19−/− ear; n = 5; two experiments). (E) Vector maps of local chemokine gradients. Arrow length and direction indicate concentration rise in CCL21 after averaging over circular surface area with indicated diameter (virtual cell size). Gray scale indicates averaged intensities. Scale bar, 15 μm. (F) Directionality of CCL21 gradients (Dc) for indicated virtual cell size as cosine of angle between direction toward closest point of LV and direction of increasing chemokine concentration. Means ± SEM for n = 6 from three independent experiments are shown. (G) Average local CCL21 concentration delta (Δ) as a function of distance to nearest LV, calculated for indicated virtual cell size. Means ± SEM for n = 7 from four independent experiments are shown.

To quantitatively analyze these interstitial gradients, we first ensured that our detection method amplified the chemokine signal linearly (fig. S4) and then measured the averaged intensity of interstitial CCL21 staining as a function of distance from the LV margin. Integration of data from multiple ear sheets revealed that the mean CCL21 signal steeply decayed around the vessel and flattened in the intervessel area (Fig. 2D and fig. S5, A and B). Stainings for CCL19 with identical secondary reagents revealed a uniform pattern of background signal in both CCL19-deficient and control tissues. This background signal invariably approached the leveled-out CCL21 signal remote from the vessel (Fig. 2D and fig. S5, C to G). The slopes of CCL21 gradients appeared smooth upon signal integration over large areas or multiple samples. However, migrating single cells have only access to local information, which exhibited considerably more noise, with local concentration peaks that could potentially trap the cells on their path to the vessel. The widely accepted spatial paradigm of eukaryotic (as opposed to prokaryotic) gradient sensing assumes that cells quantitatively detect concentration differences over their entire surface and polarize toward higher concentrations (17). Hence, we calculated vector maps of the local gradients as they would be sensed by a cell of a given diameter. For cell diameters below 9 μm, no coherent vector field emerged (Fig. 2E and movie S3). When assuming a cell size of 15 to 50 μm, which reflects the fluctuating span of a migrating DC (Fig. 1E), we retrieved vector fields pointing from the interstitium toward the next vessel for CCL21 but not for control stainings (Fig. 2, E and F, and movie S2). We next computed average local concentration deltas for given cell sizes as a function of distance from the vessel. For an assumed cell size of 36 μm, this "functional gradient" faded at a distance of 75 to 90 μm from the vessel wall (Fig. 2G) and thus matched the migratory behavior of the cells that increased directionality in a similar perimeter around the vessel as we have shown above (Fig. 1C). To estimate how well the detected gradients comply with the distribution of LVs within the dermis, we calculated distance maps of afferent LVs over large areas. We found that a cell that is randomly localized within the interstitium would need to travel an average distance of 47 ± 3 μm to reach the nearest LV (fig. S6, A and B) and that 92% of the interstitial space lies within a 90-μm perimeter around the LV network (fig. S6C). In accordance with this, endpoint analysis of intravasation assays only occasionally revealed few cells that were left "stranded" in the middle between vessels with large spacing (fig. S6D). These data demonstrate a relative invariability of the intervessel distance and imply that the range of the CCL21 gradient is very well adapted to the distribution of LVs in the skin.

We next challenged our correlative evidence for DC guidance by a CCL21 gradient using experimental manipulations. To test to what degree a continuous release of CCL21 is required to maintain the gradient, we extensively washed the ear explants and performed migration assays in the presence of brefeldin A to terminate possible chemokine secretion from LVs. Because we previously found that CCL21 can be proteolytically cleaved at the C terminus by a DC-associated protease (18), we also pharmacologically blocked this putative cleavage event, which might cause solubilization of CCL21. In both cases, we found that cells still approached LVs (fig. S7, A and B) and conclude that a continuous release of CCL21 is dispensable for directed DC migration within the approximate 2-hour time window of our assays. This suggests that the functionally active CCL21 gradient is stored within the homeostatic dermis.

In contrast to CCL19, CCL21 has a highly charged C-terminal extension that binds glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) and is thought to immobilize the chemokine to extracellular matrix or cell surfaces (18, 19). Our previous findings together with the fact that we could detect CCL21 gradients by histological methods, which necessarily include washing steps where unbound proteins are removed, were consistent with the assumption that CCL21 in the dermis is not soluble. We therefore performed a series of experiments in which we perturbed the distribution of endogenous CCL21 by addition of exogenous chemokine. To this end, we pre-incubated ear explants with an excess of exogenous recombinant CCL21, washed them to remove the soluble CCL21 fraction, and quantified the impact on gradient shapes and DC migration. We found that exogenous CCL21 diffusely localized within the dermal interstitium and thereby masked and flattened the endogenous CCL21 gradients (Fig. 3A and fig. S8A). In the pretreated explants, a large fraction of DCs was misguided within the interstitium and ultimately remained scattered remote from the vessels (Fig. 3, B to D; fig. S8B; and movie S4). Additionally, pretreatment of the explants with a C-terminally truncated version of CCL21, which is incapable of binding GAGs (19), as well as with a GAG-binding but nonsignaling mutant did not change the migratory pattern of the cells (Fig. 3D and fig. S8C). To exclude that exogenous CCL21 affects DC migration nonspecifically, for example, by masking electrostatic interactions, we pretreated ear explants with exogenous CXCL13 and CXCL12, which also bind GAGs (20) yet do not trigger CCR7, and saw no significant effects on DC migration (Fig. 3D and fig. S8C). Together, these findings establish the functional activity of the immobilized CCL21 gradients that we identified before and show that, although DCs carry the receptor for and can respond to CXCL12, CCL21 gradients dominate. In addition, the chemokine pattern appears not to be determined by the distribution of CCL21 binding sites but most likely by the diffusion range of CCL21, which is trapped by sugar residues once it is released from the LVs (21).

Fig. 3

The CCL21 gradient is functional and immobilized to heparan sulfates. (A) (Left) Z-stack projection of CCL21 immunostaining (false color-coded) of nonpermeabilized ear dermis after incubation with 0.6 μg/ml CCL21. LYVE-1–positive LVs are indicated by the blue dotted line. Scale bar, 100 μm. (Right) cCCL21 after incubation with exogenous CCL21. Gray line indicates endogenous CCL21 as shown in Fig. 2. n = 3, two independent experiments. (B) Z-stack projections of DCs (red) and LYVE-1 immunostaining (green) after a 120-min co-incubation of DCs with ear sheets. Tissue was either vehicle-treated or incubated with CCL21 before addition of DCs. n = 3, two independent experiments. (C) DC tracks (light gray lines) from representative 60-min movie with CCL21 pre-incubation, overlaid onto LV mask (dark gray). (D) Number of DCs associated with LVs after 120-min crawl-in. Indicated chemokine was pre-incubated at 0.6 μg/ml before addition of DCs. Control versus CCL21, **P = 0.006; control versus CCL21trunc, P = 0.382; control versus CCL21mut, P = 0.8163, control versus CXCL13, P = 0.458; control versus CXCL12, P = 0.0642. n = 3, at least two independent experiments. (E) Z-stack projection of nonpermeabilized ear dermis stained for CCL21 (false color-coded, left) and quantification of cCCL21 (right) in nonpermeabilized ear dermis after treatment with 50 mIU heparitinase. Gray line in graph indicates endogenous CCL21 as in Fig. 2. (F) Numbers of DCs associated with LVs in ear dermis after 120 min of crawl-in. n = 5, three independent experiments (**P = 0.004). All scale bars, 100 μm. Error bars indicate SEM.

CCL21 was shown to bind via its C-terminal domain sulfated sugars like heparin, heparan, dermatan, and chondroitin sulfates with low nanomolar affinities (19, 22, 23), potentially explaining the observed long retention times of CCL21 within the dermis and the inability of C-terminally truncated CCL21 to outcompete the endogenous gradients. To test which of the sugar moieties are involved in the immobilization of CCL21, we pretreated ear explants with sugar-degrading enzymes and found that heparitinase, which effectively removed heparan sulfates (fig. S9A), severely changed the CCL21 pattern. Quantifications revealed an almost complete flattening of the gradient and a drop to signal levels similar to control stainings, whereas tissue integrity was not affected (Fig. 3E and figs. S5G, S9B, and S10A). Consequently, DC migration in heparitinase-treated explants was severely diminished (Fig. 3F and fig. S10B). Heparan sulfate distribution patterns in untreated dermis did not match these of CCL21 (fig. S9A), corroborating the concept that not the tissue-binding sites for CCL21 but rather its distribution range determines the shape of the CCL21 gradient. These findings demonstrate that, like in the lumen of blood endothelium (2), interstitial CCL21 is immobilized to heparan sulfate residues, which either decorate cell surfaces or interstitial matrix components. This immobilized chemokine fraction is sufficient to guide intravasation of DCs, whereas adhesion molecules of the integrin family are dispensable for path-finding (24).

The term "haptotaxis" was originally introduced to describe cell migration along adhesive gradients, a phenomenon that was successfully constituted in vitro but still lacks direct in vivo support (25). Interstitial guidance by heparan sulfate immobilized chemokine gradients, as demonstrated here, can be viewed as a second variant of haptotaxis. The facts that (i) many chemokines bind GAGs (26), (ii) GAG interaction is important for the leukocyte-recruiting activity of some chemokines upon instillation into animals (27), and (iii) leukocytes have the ability to migrate along immobilized chemokine gradients in vitro (28, 29) suggest that haptotaxis could be a widely used principle. Because immobilized gradients are insensitive to mechanical perturbations, they certainly constitute a robust and stable infrastructure for cellular guidance, whereas attraction by soluble gradients might be rather transient in nature.

Supplementary Materials

Materials and Methods

Figs. S1 to S10

References (30)

Movies S1 to S4

References and Notes

  1. Acknowledgments: We thank M. Frank for technical assistance and S. Cremer, P. Schmalhorst, and E. Kiermaier for critical reading of the manuscript. This work was supported by a Humboldt Foundation postdoctoral fellowship (to M.W.), the German Research Foundation (Si1323-1,2 to M.S.), the Human Frontier Science Program (HFSP-RGP0058/2011 to M.S.), the European Research Council (ERC StG 281556 to M.S.), and the Swiss National Science Foundation (31003A_127474 to D.F.L., 130488 to S.A.L.). The authors declare no conflicts of interest. The data reported in the manuscript are tabulated in the main paper and in the supplementary materials.
View Abstract

Stay Connected to Science

Navigate This Article