Synthesis of many different types of organic small molecules using one automated process

See allHide authors and affiliations

Science  13 Mar 2015:
Vol. 347, Issue 6227, pp. 1221-1226
DOI: 10.1126/science.aaa5414

A block-by-block way to manufacture molecules

Carbon-based small molecules involved in biochemistry and drug design exhibit extraordinary structural diversity. But can we come up with a general set of building blocks from which a machine could put most of them together, in assembly-line fashion? Li et al. present progress toward this goal by showcasing the range of structures available via coupling reactions of fragments bearing a specific type of boronate group. They successfully made complex polycyclic structures by stringing together a linear precursor and then coaxing it to fold back on itself. They also developed a purification method that facilitates automation of the reaction and product isolation.

Science, this issue p. 1221


Small-molecule synthesis usually relies on procedures that are highly customized for each target. A broadly applicable automated process could greatly increase the accessibility of this class of compounds to enable investigations of their practical potential. Here we report the synthesis of 14 distinct classes of small molecules using the same fully automated process. This was achieved by strategically expanding the scope of a building block–based synthesis platform to include even Csp3-rich polycyclic natural product frameworks and discovering a catch-and-release chromatographic purification protocol applicable to all of the corresponding intermediates. With thousands of compatible building blocks already commercially available, many small molecules are now accessible with this platform. More broadly, these findings illuminate an actionable roadmap to a more general and automated approach for small-molecule synthesis.

Small molecules perform many important functions in nature, medicine, and technology. However, efforts to discover and optimize new small-molecule function are often impeded by limitations in synthetic access to this class of compounds. For peptides (1) and oligonucleotides (2), the development of automated synthesis platforms removed this bottleneck. The resulting expanded access to these molecules permitted widespread exploration and applications of their functional potential. Substantial progress has also been made toward automating the synthesis of oligosaccharides (3). In each of these cases, automation was enabled by the development of a general building block–based synthesis strategy and a common purification process for the corresponding intermediates. Such standardization reduced the number of processes employed and thus decreased the number of challenges involved in automating the synthesis platform. In contrast, despite tremendous progress in the field, small-molecule syntheses typically employ strategies and purification methods that are highly customized for each target, thus requiring automation solutions to be developed on an ad hoc basis (47). To enable the more generalized automation of small-molecule synthesis, we asked whether many different types of small molecules could be prepared using a common building block–based strategy and a common purification process.

Small molecules can be very diverse in structure, as illustrated by representative compounds 1 to 14 in Fig. 1A. Synthesis of this entire set of targets using a common approach thus represents a major challenge. However, like peptides, oligonucleotides, and oligosaccharides, most natural products (such as 1 to 4) are biosynthesized via the iterative assembly of a small set of building blocks, such as malonyl coenzyme A, isopentenyl pyrophosphate, and pyruvic acid (8). Many materials and pharmaceuticals (such as 5 to 9) comprise collections of aryl and/or heteroaryl components (9). Even topologically complex natural products containing macrocyclic or polycyclic frameworks (such as 10 to 14) are usually biosynthesized via an iterative building block–based assembly of linear precursors, which are then (poly)cyclized to yield more complex molecular architectures (1012). This analysis suggests that many small molecules might be accessible via a common, biosynthesis-inspired strategy involving the iterative assembly of building blocks. Supporting this notion, we recently demonstrated that more than 75% of all polyene natural product motifs can be prepared using just 12 building blocks and one coupling reaction (13).

Fig. 1 Common building block–based approach for making many different types of small molecules.

(A) A collection of compounds representing the structural and functional diversity of small molecules. tBu, tert-butyl. (B) Analogous building block–based strategies for the synthesis of peptides and small molecules. R, amino acid side chains. (C) Synthesis of the Csp3-rich pentacyclic secodaphnane core (±)-14 via iterative Csp3 couplings to yield a linear precursor followed by biosynthesis-inspired cascade polycyclization. An x-ray crystallographic study of the N-bromoacyl derivative of 14 unambiguously confirmed the structure of 14. TIPS, triisopropylsilyl; Ph, phenyl; DMSO, dimethyl sulfoxide.

That study employed a synthesis platform analogous to iterative peptide coupling that sequentially assembles bifunctional N-methyliminodiacetic acid (MIDA) boronates (Fig. 1B) (14). Iterative cycles of coupling and deprotection are enabled by the MIDA ligand, which attenuates the reactivity of boronic acids and thus prevents undesired oligomerization. This approach is both efficient and flexible because all of the required functional groups, oxidation states, and stereochemical elements are preinstalled into the building blocks. These features are then faithfully translated into the products using the same mild and stereospecific coupling chemistry (15). Hundreds of MIDA boronates and thousands of additional halide and boronic acid building blocks are now commercially available, and natural products from most major biosynthetic pathways, including 1 to 4, have been manually synthesized in prior studies using this strategy (1619).

With this promising starting point, we set out to expand the scope of this platform to include all of the structures shown in Fig. 1A. Csp3-rich cyclic and polycyclic natural product frameworks such as 10 to 14 represent especially challenging targets and thus required a strategic advance. Because many of these molecules are biosynthesized via cyclization of modular linear precursors derived from iterative building block assembly (1012), we hypothesized that an analogous linear-to-cyclized strategy might enable this platform to access many such structures. In this approach, the same building block assembly process is used to generate a linear precursor, which is then (poly)cyclized into the topologically complex product. The stereochemical information in the building blocks is first translated into linear precursors via stereospecific couplings and then into the targeted products via stereospecific and/or stereoselective (poly)cyclization reactions. To enable such cyclizations, such linear precursors must be suitably flexible and, therefore, rich in sp3 hybridized carbons. Building block–based assembly of these precursors thus requires many Csp3 couplings, which can be challenging.

To test this linear-to-cyclized strategy, we targeted the manual synthesis of the highly complex pentacyclic secodaphnane alkaloid core 14. This core can, in theory, be derived from a much simpler linear precursor 15 via a bioinspired cyclization cascade involving amine condensation and intramolecular Diels-Alder and Prins cyclizations (20). In turn, 15 was targeted via the iterative assembly of building blocks 16 to 18 in which all of the required double bond stereochemistry is preinstalled. Csp3 coupling of 16 and 17 generates MIDA boronate intermediate 19. Deprotection of 19 yields a free boronic acid, which is engaged in another Csp3 coupling with 18 to complete the iterative assembly of linear precursor 15. The aforementioned diastereoselective cyclization cascade is then used to transform 15 into the pentacyclic alkaloid (±)-14.

Having established a strategy to access even topologically complex small molecules using the same building block–based approach, we next questioned whether a common purification protocol could also be developed and thereby enable this platform to be automated. Small-molecule synthesis typically involves purifications customized for each intermediate, such as chromatography with eluents optimized for each compound. Such customization is incompatible with generalized automated purification. Solid-phase synthesis can address this problem for peptides (1), oligonucleotides (2), oligosaccharides (3), and some organic polymers (21). In some cases, syntheses of natural products and pharmaceuticals have also been aided by solid-phase methods (22). This approach is well established, is compatible with a wide range of chemistries, and has been employed in industry (23). However, small molecules do not possess a common functional group handle for attachment to solid support, which precludes generalized application of this approach. Thus, we needed a different solution.

We recognized that each iteration of building block assembly in our platform generates a MIDA boronate as the key intermediate (Fig. 1, B and C). This led us to question whether the MIDA boronate motif could serve as a surrogate common handle for purification. In this vein, we discovered that MIDA boronates uniformly possess highly unusual binary affinity for silica gel with certain pairs of eluents (Fig. 2A). Specifically, all MIDA boronates 20 to 39, with appended fragments representing a wide range of sizes, polarities, and functional group content, show minimal mobility on thin-layer silica gel chromatography when eluting with MeOH:Et2O (Me, methyl; Et, ethyl) (Fig. 2A, left). However, all of the same MIDA boronates are rapidly eluted with tetrahydrofuran (THF) (Fig. 2A, right). This phenomenon enabled us to develop a new type of catch-and-release purification protocol applicable to any intermediate that contains a MIDA boronate. A crude reaction mixture is passed over silica gel, and the MIDA boronate is temporarily caught while excess reagents and by-products are removed via washing with MeOH:Et2O. The MIDA boronate is then cleanly released by switching the eluent to THF. The MIDA boronate motif can thus serve as both a latent reactive functional group for iterative coupling and a traceless common functional group handle for generalized purification.

Fig. 2 General purification process to enable automation.

(A) MIDA boronates uniformly show binary elution properties on silica gel thin-layer chromatography. (B) Photograph of the small-molecule synthesizer, which comprises three modules that execute the deprotection, coupling, and purification steps. (C) Automated synthesis of natural products, materials, pharmaceuticals, and biological probes via iterative coupling of building blocks indicated by different colors (24). TBDPSE, tert-butyldiphenylsilylethyl; TMSE, trimethylsilylethyl.

With both a common building block–based synthesis platform and a common purification method, we designed and built a synthesizer that iteratively assembles MIDA boronate building blocks in a fully automated fashion (Fig. 2B) (24). This device comprises three modules that sequentially execute the deprotection, coupling, and purification steps required for each cycle. All solutions are automatically transferred via computer-controlled syringe pumps running custom-designed software. Thus, each automated synthesis simply requires placing prepacked cartridges onto the synthesizer and pressing “start.”

The fully automated synthesis commences at the deprotection module, where THF and water are syringed into a cartridge containing the MIDA boronate and NaOH. After deprotection, the reaction is quenched and the resulting THF solution of the freshly prepared boronic acid is separated from the water-soluble MIDA ligand. The coupling module then heats and stirs a solution of the next building block and the coupling reagents. The synthesizer then adds the freshly prepared solution of boronic acid to the coupling reaction. At the end of the reaction, the synthesizer filters and transfers the crude reaction mixture to the purification module, which executes the catch-and-release purification protocol with MeOH:Et2O followed by THF. The THF solution of the purified product is then transferred directly into the deprotection module to start the next iteration of the synthesis.

To first test the capacity of this synthesizer to execute one cycle of deprotection, coupling, and purification, we subjected a series of commercially available aryl, heteroaryl, and vinyl MIDA boronates to automated deprotection and coupling with a model bifunctional building block, 4-bromophenyl MIDA boronate (24) (table S2). Using a standard set of hydrolysis conditions (NaOH, THF:H2O, 23°C, 20 min) and coupling conditions (PdXPhos, K3PO4) (25), we obtained the desired cross-coupling products in good yields and purities in all cases (table S2, entries 1 to 3). The synthesizer was also capable of executing a Csp3 coupling using Pd[P(o-tol3)]2 (tol, tolyl) and Ag2O/K2CO3 (table S2, entry 4).

Accessing many pharmaceuticals and materials represented by structures 5 to 9 requires the flexibility to link building blocks via carbon-heteroatom and/or carbon-carbon bonds. The stability of MIDA boronates toward many reaction conditions (26, 27) and the synthetic versatility of boronic acids (28) allowed us to add carbon-heteroatom bond formations to the same platform. The synthesizer successfully executed a series of automated carbon-heteroatom bond formations, including a Buchwald-Hartwig amination, O-alkylation, and amide bond formations (table S3). Despite the different reagents and by-products, the same catch-and-release process purified all of the corresponding MIDA boronate products.

Having confirmed the capacity to reliably execute single cycles of deprotection, coupling, and purification, we next targeted the automated synthesis of a wide range of linear small molecules (1 to 9) via multiple carbon-carbon and/or carbon-heteroatom bond formations (Fig. 2C). These include natural products from major biosynthetic pathways (1 to 4), materials components (5, 6), and pharmaceuticals and biological probes (7 to 9). Most of the corresponding building blocks are commercially available. Similar to automated peptide, oligonucleotide, and oligosaccharide syntheses, all of the synthesizer-generated final products were purified using standard chromatographic techniques, and any protecting groups other than MIDA were easily removed in a separate step (24). In each case, a single automated run successfully delivered the targeted small molecule in multimilligram quantities, fulfilling the requirements of most functional discovery assays.

The development of small molecules with optimized functions often requires efficient access to many structural derivatives of a parent compound. To test if this platform could enable such access, we targeted the automated preparation of many derivatives of the complex neolignan natural product ratanhine 4. In this experiment, we did not optimize any of the deprotection, coupling, or purification conditions used to construct 41 (Fig. 2C). We input four sets of building blocks representing common substructural elements found throughout the neolignan family and/or other pharmaceutically relevant motifs (Fig. 3). These building blocks included variations in oxidation states, methylation patterns, fluorine content, aromatic ring identity, and size. They also represent preprogrammed oligomer lengths of 3 to 4 units, based on whether the third building block was a bifunctional halo-MIDA boronate or a capping halide. In the event, the synthesizer successfully generated 20 out of 20 of the targeted derivatives, collectively representing all possible combinations of this four-component matrix of building blocks (Fig. 3).

Fig. 3 Automated synthesis of ratanhine derivatives.

Conditions: Deprotection – NaOH, THF:H2O. Coupling – cycle 1: Pd(OAc)2, SPhos, K2CO3, THF, 55°C, 16 hours; cycle 2: Pd(OAc)2, XPhos, K3PO4, THF, 55°C, 14 hours; cycle 3: Pd(OAc)2, SPhos, K3PO4, THF, 55°C, 24 hours. Purification – SiO2, MeOH:Et2O; THF. All protecting groups other than MIDA [R: TIPS, TBDPSE, TMSE, or Bz (benzoyl)] were successfully removed in a separate step (24). OAc, acetate.

Finally, we tested whether a wide range of macro- and polycyclic natural products and natural product–like cores (10 to 14 in Fig. 1A) could be generated using the same automated building block assembly process and the linear-to-cyclized strategy. The macrocyclic natural product citreofuran possesses both Csp3 and atropisomerism stereochemical elements (Fig. 4, entry 1). This complex target can be derived from linear precursor 76 (29), which can, in theory, be assembled from building blocks 72 to 74. All of the required stereochemical information for citreofuran is pre-encoded in the chiral nonracemic MIDA boronate building block 72. On the synthesizer, fully automated deprotection of 72, Csp3 coupling with 73, and purification yielded intermediate 75. A second round of deprotection and coupling of the resulting 2-furanyl boronic acid with 74 produced linear precursor 76. This linear precursor was then deprotected and atropdiastereoselectively macrocyclized to generate citreofuran.

Fig. 4 Synthesis of Csp3-rich macro- and polycyclic natural products and natural product–like cores.

Modular linear precursors assembled via automated Csp2 and Csp3 couplings are diastereo- and/or enantioselectively cyclized. TBAF, tetra-n-butylammonium fluoride; DEAD, diethyl azodicarboxylate; OTf, trifluoromethanesulfonate; DIBAl-H, diisobutylaluminum hydride. e.r., enantiomeric ratio; d.r., diastereomeric ratio.

Oblongolide is a norsesquiterpene γ-lactone natural product containing a 6,6,5-tricyclic core with five Csp3 stereogenic centers, one of which is quaternary (Fig. 4, entry 2). The three building blocks 44, 77, and 78 were automatically assembled via iterative Csp2 and Csp3 couplings to produce linear precursor 80. After deprotection, the linear precursor was subjected to a cascade intramolecular substrate-controlled diastereoselective Diels-Alder reaction and lactonization process (30), which defined the four contiguous stereogenic centers in oblongolide.

In cases where no Csp3 stereogenic centers are present in the linear precursors, the enantioselectivity of cyclizations can be controlled using a rapidly expanding toolbox of chiral catalysts (31). This approach allows the stereoselective construction of the natural product–like hexahydroindene and steroid-like core structures 12 and 13 using the same linear-to-cyclized strategy (Fig. 4, entries 3 and 4). Specifically, building blocks 81 to 83, all possessing olefins with predefined geometries required for cyclization, were assembled on the synthesizer to produce linear precursor 85. This precursor was then subjected to deprotection and a chiral imidazolidinone-promoted organocatalytic enantio- and diastereoselective Diels-Alder reaction to generate 12 (Fig. 4, entry 3) (32). Similarly, iterative Csp3 coupling of building blocks 16, 17, and 86 generated linear precursor 87, which then underwent catalyst-promoted enantio- and diastereoselective cation-π cyclization (33) followed by reduction to generate 13 (Fig. 4, entry 4). Finally, by simply replacing building block 86 with 18 and using the same automated platform, even the highly complex pentacyclic secodaphnane core (±)-14 was readily prepared (Fig. 4, entry 5).

Thus, many different types of small molecules (1 to 14 in Fig. 1A) can be synthesized using one automated building block assembly platform. This advance was enabled by standardizing the synthesis and purification processes used to assemble these structures. Importantly, a majority of the building blocks employed herein are already commercially available.

Further expanding the scope of this automated synthesis platform represents an actionable roadmap toward a general and broadly accessible solution to the small-molecule synthesis problem. This roadmap includes creating building blocks representing the highly redundant substructural elements found in many small molecules (13), developing better methods for iteratively coupling those building blocks together, and advancing the capacity for biosynthesis-inspired cyclizations of linear precursors to yield complex natural product frameworks. Achieving these objectives stands to better enable the scientific community to bring the substantial power of small-molecule synthesis to bear upon many important unsolved problems in society.

Supplementary Materials

Materials and Methods

Supplementary Text

Figs. S1 to S14

Tables S1 to S3

References (3452)

References and Notes

  1. Materials and methods are available as supplementary materials on Science Online.
  2. Acknowledgments: We acknowledge the NIH (grants GM080436 and GM090153), the NSF (grant 0747778), HHMI, and Bristol-Myers Squibb for funding. M.D.B. is an HHMI Early Career Scientist, J.L. was an HHMI International Student Research Fellow, and J.L. and E.P.G. were Bristol-Myers Squibb Graduate Fellows. We thank D. Gray for performing the x-ray analysis on N-bromoacyl-14. The University of Illinois has filed patent applications on MIDA boronate chemistry and the automated synthesis platform reported herein. These inventions have been licensed to REVOLUTION Medicines, a company for which M.D.B. is a founder. Metrical parameters for the structure of N-bromoacyl-14 are available free of charge from the Cambridge Cyrstallographic Data Centre under reference CCDC-1045844.
View Abstract

Stay Connected to Science


Navigate This Article