eLetters is an online forum for ongoing peer review. Submission of eLetters are open to all. eLetters are not edited, proofread, or indexed. Please read our Terms of Service before submitting your own eLetter.
- RE: Media Guidelines Discourage Reporting Evolutionary Theories of Suicide
Elizabeth Culotta’s article on evolutionary theories of suicide [1] discusses contributions by Humphrey and Soper but omits prior, more influential work by deCatanzaro who theorized that low reproductive potential and burdensomeness on kin predicted suicidality. [2] This evolutionary theory influenced Joiner’s now popular interpersonal theory, which emphasizes perceived burdensomeness. [3] Despite interviewing us for an hour, Culotta also did not mention our hypothesis, grounded in over a century of ethnography on suicide in small-scale societies, that suicidality evolved as a costly, honest signal of need. [4] When Syme wrote to inquire about these omissions, Culotta replied that in adhering to CPA media guidelines that discourage portraying “suicide as achieving results and solving problems” [5], she and the editors omitted theories proposing evolutionary benefits. She also encouraged us to write this letter.
Show More
We agree that news coverage of suicidality should take precautions. However, the exact causes mediating media coverage and suicide contagion are unknown. [5] The media guidelines, therefore, have the effect of excluding coverage of much evolutionary research on suicide, not because of a lack of scientific merit but because of an uncertain risk to some readers.
Science reporting rallies interest, frames scientific discussions, and can influence how funding agencies allocate limited resources. We are concerned that the original article has given our colle...Competing Interests: None declared. - RE: Have humans developed natural defenses against suicide?
Clifford Alan Soper tries to explain "how deliberate, intentional self-killing came to be a part of the behavioral repertoire of human species" (p. 1.). (https://www.springer.com/gp/book/9783319772998).
Nicholas Humphrey thinks that "A person who can see through the logic behind her suicidal impulses may be best placed to resist them".
Humphrey is asking about ontogeny; Soper is asking about phylogeny.
So, "Have humans developed natural defenses against suicide?" Does ontogeny recapitulate phylogeny?
Competing Interests: None declared.











