Essays on Science and SocietyNeuromodulation

Seeing the sound

See allHide authors and affiliations

Science  07 Aug 2020:
Vol. 369, Issue 6504, pp. 638
DOI: 10.1126/science.abd3636

Optogenetics, which uses light to control genetically modified neurons, is revolutionizing neuroscience research by allowing for the precise deconstruction of neural circuits with neuron type specificity (1, 2). However, due to limited tissue penetration of visible light, invasive craniotomy and intracranial implantation of obtrusive optical fibers or light-emitting diodes (LEDs) are usually required for in vivo optogenetic neural modulation in the brains of rodents and other mammalian subjects (3). Perturbation of the endogenous neural and glial activity has been reported as a consequence of chronic gliosis at the implant/neural interface, as has permanent damage to neural tissue (47).


Embedded Image

The Challenge of Invasive Optogenetics

The need for invasive delivery of a light source represents a long-standing challenge for in vivo optogenetics. This need is because visible photons can only achieve limited penetration in brain tissue (8). The conventional optogenetic toolbox comprises opsins with activation spectra in the range of 430 to 610 nm that have limited tissue penetration due to scattering and absorption of photons by the brain tissue (9). Several strategies have been employed to increase penetration, including the use of opsins with red-shifted activation spectra (10, 11), two-photon stimulation of opsins (12), and conversion of brain-penetrant near-infrared light into visible photons via intracortically injected upconversion nanoparticles (13, 14).

Despite these advances, such approaches are still invasive, requiring either partial removal of the scalp and skull (10, 12) or intracranial delivery of nanomaterials into deep brain tissue (13, 14).

Converting Sound Into Light

Our approach (15) to address this challenge has been to replace direct light illumination with focused ultrasound (FUS), which affords much deeper penetration (∼5 cm for FUS versus 100 µm for visible photons) in biological tissues, including the brain (1619). However, ultrasound does not activate opsins directly. Thus, a local transducer that converts sound into light in the brain is required.

I am a materials scientist with extensive training in neurobiology (7), and am therefore aware of the types of materials that can absorb sound waves and emit light in return. Such substances, known as mechanoluminescent materials, have previously been used primarily in dynamic stress mapping of structures (20), displays (21, 22), and photonic skins (23). If these materials could be delivered to a deep brain region, they could become a light source that can be turned on and off by FUS from outside the brain.

In our study, we made zinc sulfide (ZnS) nanoparticles co-doped with trace amounts of silver (Ag) and cobalt (Co) to afford the mechanoluminescence property. Unlike pristine, dopant-free ZnS, which is a photoluminescent material with a submicrosecond lifetime after 400-nm photoexcitation, Co dopant ions trap the excited electrons and store the photoexcitation energy until being triggered by FUS. Ag dopant ions tune the emission color to 470-nm blue light for activation of channelrhodopsin-2 (ChR2) (Fig. 1A).

An Endogenous Mechanism to Deliver and Recharge the Nanoscopic Light Source

This method, however, has a substantial drawback: Because 400-nm photoexcitation is required to “precharge” the nanoparticles and FUS simply controls when light should be emitted by releasing the trapped energy (Fig. 1A), the material must be charged with 400-nm irradiation outside the brain before delivery into deep tissue and can only be triggered once by FUS.

Our solution to this problem is made possible by the pervasive nature of the blood circulation inside the body. Not only do blood vessels penetrate the entire brain, allowing delivery of ZnS nanoparticles to any region; blood also passes through superficial vessels near the skin, providing accessible locations shallow enough for 400-nm light to penetrate and recharge these nanoscopic light sources as they circulate in the body. After the ZnS nanoparticles are injected intravenously, they can be charged by 400-nm light when passing through superficial vessels, pumped by the heart into cerebral vessels, and then gated by FUS to release the stored energy locally, all without exiting the blood circulation (Fig. 1B).

Fig. 1. Sono-optogenetics facilitated by mechanoluminescent materials and the endogenous circulatory system. (A) Mechanism of ultrasound-triggered light emission from ZnS nanoparticles co-doped with Ag and Co. In this drawing, the electron trap is created in the host material of ZnS by Co2+ dopant ions, causing the photoexcited electrons to be trapped after absorption of 400-nm excitation light. FUS allows the trapped electrons to transfer energy into the luminescent centers created by Ag+ dopant ions, resulting in 470-nm light emission. (B) Schematic showing blood circulation of mechanoluminescent ZnS nanoparticles, transporting the continuous 400-nm photoexcitation energy at superficial vessels into FUS-gated 470-nm emission in deep brain regions for optogenetic stimulation. (C) Intensity of the 470-nm emission from mechanoluminescent ZnS nanoparticles in an artificial circulatory system under repetitive FUS stimulation (red ticks) and continuous 400-nm recharging light (violet bar). (D) Schematic of in vivo sono-optogenetic stimulation. Mechanoluminescent ZnS nanoparticles are injected intravenously via the tail vein, the 400-nm recharging light is placed near the neck skin, and the FUS transducer is placed on the intact mouse head. (E) Left: Photographs of a Thy1-ChR2-YFP mouse (top) and a wild-type (WT) mouse (bottom) during sono-optogenetic stimulation through intact scalp and skull, before and after injection of mechanoluminescent ZnS nanoparticles. Right: Statistics of left hindlimb displacement in different groups of subjects (n = 3 per group) in response to FUS excitation. The bar heights indicate the mean; error bars indicate SEM. ****P < 0.0001; N.S., not significant; FUS, Focused Ultrasound.

GRAPHIC: ADAPTED FROM G. HONG BY N. DESAI/SCIENCE

Sono-Optogenetics: A Rechargeable Light Source Inside the Body

We investigated the feasibility of such an approach first in an artificial circulatory system, where we were able to confirm that the nanoparticles light up, recharge, and light up again without losing intensity (Fig. 1C). The average intensity of FUS-triggered light emission is ∼1 mW/mm2, an amount sufficient to activate ChR2 (24).

We then carried out in vivo experiments, injecting the nanoparticles into the tail vein of mice that expressed ChR2 in the motor cortex. We positioned the shaved mouse head underneath a transducer that aimed ultrasound at the motor cortex of the brain (Fig. 1D). Then—without any surgery to the scalp, skull, or brain, and without any implantation of optical fiber or LED devices—we were able to evoke hindlimb motion in the animal, which was synchronized with the FUS pulses. The same animal did not exhibit any hindlimb motion before nanoparticle injection under the same stimulation protocol, nor did wild-type mice demonstrate any hindlimb motion, regardless of nanoparticle injection (Fig. 1E).

In our approach, which we refer to as “sono-optogenetics,” the focal size of FUS in the mouse brain is ∼700 µm. The localized light source thus has a similar cross-sectional diameter in the brain. Additionally, FUS can be turned on and off with submillisecond precision, with a latency time of 10 ms before light emission. These features have made the virtual light source in our work similar to conventional fiber optics in both spatial and temporal resolution (3).

Sono-optogenetics provides a tool for rapidly screening different target regions in the brain for optogenetic neural modulation, because one can easily change the location of ultrasound focus. We envisage that this approach will also be able to be used in other organs that are usually refractory to fiber implantation (e.g., spinal cord, heart, and lungs) and for any application in which a light source is needed deep in the body.


Embedded Image
PHOTO: COURTESY OF GUOSONG HONG

FINALIST

Guosong Hong

Guosong Hong received his undergraduate degree from Peking University and a Ph.D. from Stanford University. After completing his postdoctoral fellowship at Harvard University, Guosong started his lab in the Department of Materials Science and Engineering and the Wu Tsai Neurosciences Institute at Stanford University in 2018. His research aims to develop new materials-enabled neurotechnologies to interrogate and manipulate the brain with high spatiotemporal resolution, minimal invasiveness, and targeted neural specificity. www.sciencemag.org/content/369/6504/638

References and Notes

View Abstract

Stay Connected to Science

Navigate This Article