We tested 20 hypothesized associations between song and other behaviors by comparing the frequency of a behavior in song-related passages to that in comparably-sized samples of text from the same sources that are not about song. Behavior was identified with two methods: topic annotations from the Outline of Cultural Materials (“OCM identifiers”) and automatic detection of related keywords (“WordNet seed words”; see table S19). Significance tests compared the frequencies in the passages in the full Probability Sample File containing song-related keywords (“Song freq.”) with the frequencies in a simulated null distribution of passages randomly selected from the same documents (“Null freq.”). ***P < 0.001, **P < 0.01, *P < 0.05, using adjusted P values (88); 95% intervals for the null distribution are in parentheses.
Hypothesis | OCM identifier(s) | Song freq. | Null freq. | WordNet seed word(s) | Song freq. | Null freq. |
Dance | DANCE | 1499*** | 431 (397, 467) | dance | 11,145*** | 3283 (3105, 3468) |
Infancy | INFANT CARE | 63* | 44 (33, 57) | infant, baby, cradle, lullaby | 688** | 561 (491, 631) |
Healing | MAGICAL AND MENTAL THERAPY; SHAMANS AND PSYCHOTHERAPISTS; MEDICAL THERAPY; MEDICAL CARE | 1651*** | 1063 (1004, 1123) | heal, shaman, sick, cure | 3983*** | 2466 (2317, 2619) |
Religious activity | SHAMANS AND PSYCHOTHERAPISTS; RELIGIOUS EXPERIENCE; PRAYERS AND SACRIFICES; PURIFICATION AND ATONEMENT; ECSTATIC RELIGIOUS PRACTICES; REVELATION AND DIVINATION; RITUAL | 3209*** | 2212 (2130, 2295) | religious, spiritual, ritual | 8644*** | 5521 (5307, 5741) |
Play | GAMES; CHILDHOOD ACTIVITIES | 377*** | 277 (250, 304) | play, game, child, toy | 4130*** | 2732 (2577, 2890) |
Procession | SPECTACLES; NUPTIALS | 371*** | 213 (188, 240) | wedding, parade, march, procession, funeral, coronation | 2648*** | 1495 (1409, 1583) |
Mourning | BURIAL PRACTICES AND FUNERALS; MOURNING; SPECIAL BURIAL PRACTICES AND FUNERALS | 924*** | 517 (476, 557) | mourn, death, funeral | 3784*** | 2511 (2373, 2655) |
Ritual | RITUAL | 187*** | 99 (81, 117) | ritual, ceremony | 8520** | 5138 (4941, 5343) |
Entertainment | SPECTACLES | 44*** | 20 (12, 29) | entertain, spectacle | 744*** | 290 (256, 327) |
Children | CHILDHOOD ACTIVITIES | 178*** | 108 (90, 126) | child | 4351*** | 3471 (3304, 3647) |
Mood/emotions | DRIVES AND EMOTIONS | 219*** | 138 (118, 159) | mood, emotion, emotive | 796*** | 669 (607, 731) |
Work | LABOR AND LEISURE | 137*** | 60 (47, 75) | work, labor | 3500** | 3223 (3071, 3378) |
Storytelling | VERBAL ARTS; LITERATURE | 736*** | 537 (506, 567) | story, history, myth | 2792*** | 2115 (1994, 2239) |
Greeting visitors | VISITING AND HOSPITALITY | 360*** | 172 (148, 196) | visit, greet, welcome | 1611*** | 1084 (1008, 1162) |
War | WARFARE | 264 | 283 (253, 311) | war, battle, raid | 3154*** | 2254 (2122, 2389) |
Praise | STATUS, ROLE, AND PRESTIGE | 385 | 355 (322, 388) | praise, admire, acclaim | 481*** | 302 (267, 339) |
Love | ARRANGING A MARRIAGE | 158 | 140 (119, 162) | love, courtship | 1625*** | 804 (734, 876) |
Group bonding | SOCIAL RELATIONSHIPS AND GROUPS | 141 | 163 (141, 187) | bond, cohesion | 1582*** | 1424 (1344, 1508) |
Marriage/weddings | NUPTIALS | 327*** | 193 (169, 218) | marriage, wedding | 2011 | 2256 (2108, 2410) |
Art/creation | N/A | n/a | n/a | art, creation | 905*** | 694 (630, 757) |